Presidential Office’s Request for Renomination

Chief Justice Choi Hee-dae has announced that he will clarify his position regarding the ongoing conflict with the Presidential Office over the nomination of Supreme Court justices through future National Assembly audits or other relevant venues.

Chief Justice Hoe-Dae Cho is answering questions from reporters as he arrives at the Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul on the 28th. Photo by Yonhap News

Chief Justice Hoe-Dae Cho is answering questions from reporters as he arrives at the Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul on the 28th. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

On the morning of September 28 as he arrived at the Supreme Court building in Seocho-gu, Seoul, Chief Justice Choi was asked by reporters about his view on the recommendation of candidate Son Bong-gi. He stated, "If there is something absolutely necessary in the future, I will convey it through the spokesperson during the parliamentary audit or similar occasions."


Previously, on August 18, Chief Justice Choi broke with tradition and submitted a nomination for Son Bong-gi after failing to reach an agreement with the Presidential Office over the recommendation of candidates for the Supreme Court. On August 28, the Presidential Office rejected Son Bong-gi’s nomination, describing it as a "unilateral written recommendation without substantive consultation," and requested a resubmission.


However, on September 22—25 days after the Presidential Office’s request—Chief Justice Choi officially stated, "I cannot comply with the request for resubmission." He explained that the official document requesting resubmission did not specify particular reasons or constitutional grounds, and there was also no other constitutional basis or justification to legitimize such a request.


In response, the Presidential Office immediately countered, saying, "Chief Justice Choi’s statement implies that the chief justice’s power of recommendation takes precedence over the president’s authority to appoint, which is a perception that violates the Constitution."


Subsequently, when Chief Justice Choi reiterated that "the reasoning for the resubmission request is not clearly stated in the official letter," the Presidential Office replied, "The meaning of the document is clear, yet the chief justice is misleading the facts."



Meanwhile, on October 13 last year, Chief Justice Choi attended the National Assembly’s Legislation and Judiciary Committee’s audit of the Supreme Court, where he read his prepared remarks as the agency head, as is customary. He did not answer questions from Democratic Party lawmakers without first taking an oath as a witness, and left the session after about an hour.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing