Former EcoproBM Executive Director Acquitted

The former CEO of an Ecopro affiliate, who had been tried for trading stocks using undisclosed material information, has been sentenced to prison, while the former executive director was acquitted. The Supreme Court ruled that an announcement stating the company was "considering a bonus issue" could not be deemed as public disclosure of the bonus issue information.

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on September 28, the Supreme Court’s 3rd Division (Presiding Justice Oh Seokjun) recently upheld the previous court rulings in the appeal trial of the former CEO (A) of Ecopro's subsidiary EcoproHN and the former business planning executive director (B) of EcoproBM, both of whom had been indicted for violating the Capital Markets Act. As a result, A received a prison sentence of one year and six months, a fine of 1.5 billion won, and a forfeiture of approximately 618.48 million won, while B was acquitted.


A was accused of using prior knowledge, during his tenure as CEO, that EcoproHN would carry out a bonus issue, to acquire shares before the official disclosure on July 7 and 15, 2021, thereby obtaining illegal gains of 78.05 million won. He was also alleged to have traded stocks using information about EcoproBM’s third-quarter 2021 sales figures before their public release, earning approximately 540.43 million won in unfair profits.


A’s side argued that the information regarding the bonus issue was already public, citing EcoproHN’s July 7, 2021, announcement stating the company was "currently reviewing a bonus issue." They further claimed that the EcoproBM sales information was not material information.


The first and second trials did not accept this argument. The court of first instance stated, “An announcement merely saying that a bonus issue is under review does not constitute disclosure of information related to the bonus issue to the general public.” The court reasoned that the disclosure only indicated the company was planning to consider a bonus issue in the future and left room for changes, with no specifics about the timing or ratio of the bonus issue. Therefore, investors could not immediately make investment decisions based only on the disclosure content.


The court of appeal also pointed out, “The announcement in question did not include the specific timing, scale, or share allocation ratio of the bonus issue—core matters that directly influence actual investment decisions.” The appellate court held that the information was made public only after a subsequent disclosure specifying the detailed schedule and ratio had been issued.


Regarding the sales figure information, the first instance court said, “A rational investor could assess EcoproBM's market dominance, growth potential, and future profitability from the third-quarter sales figures and could decide on purchasing shares accordingly. Such sales data constitutes material information that can have a significant impact on the share price.” The appellate court also deemed that, given the market trend and circumstances at the time, the third-quarter sales figures qualified as undisclosed material information.


However, the court found A not guilty in instances where he profited approximately 51.83 million won by buying shares based on bonus issue-related information between June 29 and July 1, 2021. He was also acquitted of making 40.54 million won by trading stocks using information about the parent company Ecopro's third-quarter operating results prior to their public release.


B was acquitted of charges that he had used non-public information about a mid- to long-term secondary supply agreement for high-nickel cathode materials for electric vehicles, supplied by EcoproBM, to buy shares prior to its disclosure, thereby gaining an illegal profit of approximately 1.40747 billion won.


The first trial had found B guilty of using supply contract information, sentencing him to one year and six months in prison, a fine of 2.2 billion won, and confiscating approximately 1.40747 billion won. However, the appeals court overturned the guilty ruling and acquitted him, reasoning that it was not proven beyond a reasonable doubt that B used non-public, material information related to the supply contract to acquire shares and make unlawful gains.



The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, stating that the lower court did not misunderstand the legal principles regarding the establishment of the offense under the Capital Markets Act, the concept of undisclosed material information, or the use of such information.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing