Supreme Court: Disclosure That a "Free Capital Increase Is Under Review" Does Not Constitute Public Disclosure

The Supreme Court has ruled that a disclosure stating that a "free capital increase is under review" does not constitute public disclosure of a planned free capital increase to the general public.

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on September 28, the Supreme Court's third division (Presiding Justice Oh Seokjun) recently upheld the original verdict, sentencing Mr. A, former CEO of EcoproHN, a subsidiary of Ecopro, to one year and six months in prison, a fine of 1.5 billion won, and the forfeiture of approximately 618 million won.


Mr. A was indicted for violating the Capital Markets Act on charges of making improper gains of approximately 130 million won by purchasing shares between June 29 and July 15, 2021, before the fact that EcoproHN would conduct a free capital increase was officially disclosed. He was also accused of earning unjust profits of around 540 million won by trading shares using unpublished sales information for the third quarter of 2021 from another subsidiary, EcoproBM, before this information was released.


Mr. A claimed that, on July 7, 2021, EcoproHN had announced that it was "currently reviewing the implementation of a free capital increase." He also argued that the sales information of EcoproBM was not considered significant information.


The first and second trial courts did not accept these arguments and found Mr. A guilty. The court of first instance stated, "A disclosure merely indicating that the implementation of a free capital increase is under review is not enough to say that information related to it has been made public to an unspecified majority."


The ruling explained that the disclosure only stated EcoproHN was reviewing a potential free capital increase, left room for possible changes, and did not specify either the timing or the ratio of the increase. From the perspective of outside investors, it would be difficult to make immediate decisions regarding investment amount, timing, or participation based solely on such disclosure. Mr. A also maintained his claim that the sales information was not significant information.


The first instance court found, "A rational investor could, through the third-quarter sales information, assess EcoproBM's market dominance, growth potential, and future profitability, and decide whether to purchase shares accordingly. Sales figures constitute significant information that has a substantial impact on share prices."


The appellate court also pointed out, "The relevant disclosure did not include critical details such as the specific timing, scale of the capital increase, or allocation ratio of new shares, all of which are essential for investors to make actual investment decisions." Regarding the charges of using EcoproBM's sales figures, the ruling stated, "Given the stock price trends and market environment at the time, information about third-quarter sales qualified as undisclosed material information."


However, Mr. A had also been charged with making about 40 million won by trading Ecopro shares, the parent company, using information about its third-quarter operating profit and current sales before those figures were disclosed in 2021, but this charge was found not guilty.



The Supreme Court determined that there was no error in the lower court's judgment and upheld Mr. A's sentence as is.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing