No Legal Path for Establishing Time-Limited Public-Interest Foundations
Prior Regulation from Fundraising to Expenditure
Public-Interest Commission Bill Still Pending in National Assembly

The 'Gates Foundation', established by world-renowned philanthropist Bill Gates, will close its doors on December 31, 2045. This so-called 'Sunset Foundation' model involves dedicating most of his $200 billion (approximately KRW 270 trillion) fortune to public interest projects over the next 20 years and then dissolving the foundation. Gates stated, "I never intended to operate the foundation permanently," and explained, "Charitable activities are most effective when addressing problems intensively within a set timeframe." The Gates Foundation is currently engaged in global public interest initiatives across various fields, such as fighting infectious diseases, developing new drugs, alleviating poverty, improving education, and reducing inequality related to artificial intelligence (AI).


However, the reality in Korea makes it virtually impossible to establish an ultra-large public interest foundation where asset holders can freely contribute their shares and wealth and decide how they are used, as Gates has done. Even if successful entrepreneurs or high-net-worth individuals are determined to give back to society, current laws, regulations, and tax burdens become obstacles, making a 'Korean version of the Gates Foundation' structurally impossible.

Donation of Wealthy Individuals Blocked by Various Regulations. AI Generated Image

Donation of Wealthy Individuals Blocked by Various Regulations. AI Generated Image

View original image

Public Interest Corporations Hampered by Legal Barriers

The Public Interest Corporation Act (Act on the Establishment and Operation of Public Interest Corporations) was enacted in 1975 to separately manage nonprofit corporations conducting certain public interest projects, such as scholarships, academic activities, or charity work. To establish a public interest corporation under this law, an organization must meet the requirements for stable finances, operational capacity, and transparency before obtaining approval from the overseeing authority.


The problem is that this law is far more regulatory than the Civil Act. When founding a foundation, the government applies the principle that basic assets must not be depleted, assuming 'perpetual operation.' As a result, the 'Sunset Foundation' model—where all endowments are spent in accordance with the donor's wishes and then the foundation is dissolved—is not permitted from the outset.


Approval from the competent authority is also mandatory when disposing of or providing basic assets as collateral. If the exemption to include assets as basic assets is not granted, the disposal rights of virtually all assets are controlled by the supervising agency. Unlike the Gates Foundation, which can flexibly address various social issues, Korean public interest corporations struggle to freely expand their business areas.


In fact, one public interest foundation could not pay research staff wages even though donors had made regular contributions for that very purpose; the overseeing agency rejected their request for an asset exemption. The foundation was finally able to obtain approval only after filing an administrative lawsuit.


There is also a provision that requires the remaining assets of a dissolved public interest corporation to revert to the state or a local government. Regarding this, Bae Wonki, President of the Korea Nonprofit Evaluation Institute, emphasized, "Since residual assets are also created through private donations, the law should ensure flexibility in capital management, allowing such assets to be transferred to another private entity with similar purposes."

[Regulation-Bound NPO③] "Social Contribution Not Allowed at Will"… Barriers Block a 'Korean Gates Foundation' View original image

'State Surveillance' Even on KRW 10 Million Donations

There are strict regulations even in the fundraising process. If more than KRW 10 million is to be raised from the general public, pre-registration is required under the Fundraising Act (Act on the Collection and Use of Donations and Promotion of Donation Culture). Violators can face up to three years in prison. [Related Article = Lee Heesook, "Re-examine the Fundraising Act, a Legacy of Pro-Japanese Regulation"]


Bae pointed out, "On the ground, there are even bizarre situations where fundraising is forcibly stopped once the amount reaches KRW 9.99 million, just to avoid the risk of criminal penalties. There is already a mechanism for post-facto transparency verification under the Tax Act, so requiring pre-registration in the fundraising phase constitutes overlapping regulation and administrative waste."


The Fundraising Act also requires that donations be used according to the pre-declared purpose, all funds be spent within two years, and administrative expenses be kept below 15% of the total. This makes it difficult to respond immediately to urgent social issues due to complex procedures, and organizations unaware of the regulations can unwittingly become lawbreakers.

Push to Establish Public Interest Commission...Already Adopted in Australia and the UK

The government has also recognized the issue of excessive regulation and has been pushing for the establishment of a 'Public Interest Commission' control tower to oversee the establishment, management, and supervision of public interest corporations. While it was a policy initiative during the Moon Jae-in administration but was not realized, Minister of the Interior and Safety Yoon Hojoong continued the efforts. Since assuming office, he introduced a repeal bill for the Public Interest Corporation Act, an amendment to the Fundraising Act, legislation to establish the Public Interest Commission, and amendments to the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act to facilitate stock donations—but all remain pending in the National Assembly, with discussions yet to begin.


The bill to establish a Public Interest Commission includes provisions for the commission, under the Prime Minister’s Office, to handle approval, management, and oversight of public interest corporations exclusively. The commission may approve a corporation as one serving the public interest once all eligibility requirements are met. To enhance transparency and invigorate public interest activities, the commission would also support development of specialists and training. Additionally, if a public interest corporation submits a fundraising plan to the commission, it may be granted exemptions from certain provisions of the Fundraising Act.

[Regulation-Bound NPO③] "Social Contribution Not Allowed at Will"… Barriers Block a 'Korean Gates Foundation' View original image

In Australia, the Australian Charities and Not-for-profit Commission (ACNC) centrally manages public interest organizations, and registered entities receive tax relief from the National Tax Office. Organizations with political purposes or opposed to public policy are excluded from registration, and entities found in violation have their registrations revoked—highlighting a strong enforcement system. Similarly, in the United Kingdom, a charity commission oversees public interest organizations and receives annual fundraising reports from them. Organizations registered with the commission are automatically recognized as public interest corporations for tax purposes, without any additional designation process, and the regulation of donation use is unified under the tax authority’s oversight.

"NPOs Are Partners of the State...Diversity Is Needed"

Stakeholders in the nonprofit sector emphasize that their organizations have played a crucial role in complementing government capacity and market limitations, thereby contributing to societal progress and the restoration of community. Kim Deoksan, Chairman of the Korea Public Interest Foundation Association, stated, "Public interest corporations have long served as partners to the state in solving social problems," and added, "Consumer groups led the distribution of convenience store medicines, and the so-called 'Jung-in Law,' which increased sentences for child abuse, was achieved through the efforts of child protection groups." He stressed, "Despite this, the government still regards public interest corporations only as subjects of control and supervision. Lowering the barriers to establishment and operation, and strengthening autonomy and expertise within the ecosystem, are crucial for building a healthy society."


Bang Daeuk, CEO of Daum Foundation, which has supported and nurtured over 50 nonprofit startups, said, "As society becomes more complex and the technological environment changes rapidly, more NPOs that approach issues in new ways must emerge." He also pointed out that the vast majority of donations go to a small number of large organizations, saying, "Ensuring diversity in the nonprofit ecosystem is essential to a healthy market and to solving a wide range of social issues."



According to the first-ever 'Annual Report on Public Interest Corporations' published by the National Tax Service in May this year, the number of public interest corporations that published annual financial statements last year reached 21,318, with their total donation income amounting to KRW 11 trillion. The top 15 organizations, including the Community Chest of Korea, World Vision, and Good Neighbors, accounted for KRW 4 trillion, or 38% of the total donation income, illustrating the concentration of resources. Bang concluded, "NPOs should be organizations solving social problems—not spending their energy on administration. The regulatory system should not obstruct nonprofit activities but be a foundation for enabling them to do their work better."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing