[Regulated NPO ④] Heesook Lee: "Reexamine the 'Act on the Collection of Donations', a Legacy of Pro-Japanese Regulations"
State Surveillance and Restrictions on Public-Interest Activities
Regulation Is Counterproductive When the Focus Should Be on Encouraging Donations
Growth of the Third Sector Is Essential for Stable Social Development
"The root of the Donations and Funds Act lies in a regulation created by pro-Japanese collaborator Lee Wan-yong, which was designed to suppress movements that resisted Japan, such as national education initiatives. We need to fundamentally re-examine whether this law should still exist today."
Hee-Sook Lee, Standing Attorney at Dongcheon Foundation, stated this in a recent interview with The Asia Business Daily, adding, "The Donations and Funds Act reflects the perspective of pro-Japanese state power that sought to control national self-reliance and independence movements."
The Donations and Funds Act requires prior registration with the Ministry of the Interior and Safety or local governments when raising more than 10 million won from the general public and lays out procedures for the state to regulate fundraising and the use of funds. While the stated purpose is to create a 'sound donation culture,' the law faces ongoing criticism in practice that 'the state surveils the public sector's activities and assesses them with administrative criteria.'
Attorney Lee, while investigating the origins of the Donations and Funds Act, discovered that the 1909 'Rules on the Supervision of Fundraising' serve as the basis for the current law. At that time, there is a recorded case of independence activist Jeon Hong-pyo being caught raising funds for the funeral of his disciple Choi Soo-bong, who was executed for resisting Japanese rule, and then being sentenced to prison under these regulations. She noted, "Even after the liberation, such regulations were repeatedly imposed. Although the permit system has now shifted to a registration system, the fundamental structure remains largely unchanged. The focus should shift from a regulation-oriented law to one that supports revitalization, leaving only a minimum set of precautions for fundraising activities."
She filed a motion for constitutional review concerning Article 32 of the Civil Code's 'permit system for establishment,' during an administrative lawsuit against the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family's rejection of a nonprofit entity established by the law firm Bae, Kim & Lee. The Seoul Administrative Court decided to request a constitutional review on the following grounds: the lack of statutory criteria for permits, the potential infringement on freedom of association, and differential treatment compared to for-profit companies. She explained, "Although the decision of the Constitutional Court will take time, both the legal and academic communities believe that there is a strong chance of an unconstitutional ruling."
She pointed out that the permit system poses significant restrictions on the operation of nonprofit organizations. For example, when an organization votes to amend its articles of incorporation at a general meeting and applies for approval, if the relevant authority finds fault with even one regulation, approval is denied and the general meeting must be reconvened. In addition, there are many cases in which organizations have attempted to expand their scope of activities, only to have their proposed amendments rejected on the grounds that "the new business does not fall under the authority's jurisdiction," thereby blocking a variety of convergence projects.
She emphasized that nonprofit and public-interest corporations are "not merely charitable groups, but essential pillars of the civic community and society," and that it is time to shift away from regulation-focused laws and systems. She stated that for society to develop in a stable manner, nonprofit and public-interest entities—as a third sector alongside government and business—must be allowed to grow in a balanced way. She added, "As artificial intelligence (AI) spreads and job disruptions worsen amid increasing life expectancy, the revitalization of the civic community will become essential for enhancing the quality of life in old age and strengthening the social safety net."
Lastly, Attorney Lee stressed, "If the permit system is strictly maintained on the grounds that management is challenging, the result may be a shrinking civil society. The government should abandon the idea that it must manage all corporate bodies, and move toward a system—like that found overseas—where associations can be established freely, while only those corporations enjoying benefits such as tax reductions are subject to oversight."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Meanwhile, Dongcheon Foundation is a public-interest foundation established by Bae, Kim & Lee in 2009, specializing in and systematically carrying out Bae, Kim & Lee's public-interest initiatives. Attorney Lee has continued to provide legal support for socially vulnerable groups such as North Korean defectors and children, as well as advocating for improvements in nonprofit regulations, for the past 11 years.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.