[Seismic Delivery Market]②Will Consumers Still Use Delivery Apps Without Free Delivery?... Consumer Benefits Under Threat
Concerns Grow Over Consumer Costs as Commission Legislation Gains Momentum
Market Contraction Could Backfire on Consumers, Riders, and Vendors Alike
The South Korean food delivery app market is on the verge of seismic change. Legislative efforts to cap platform commissions and sanctions from the Korea Fair Trade Commission on delivery platforms are making shifts in the market environment inevitable. As the dominant player, Baemin (Baedal Minjok), experiences a change in ownership, it too stands at a crossroads. However, this market shake-up does not affect just one sector. Delivery apps, now essential to daily life with over 20 million users, are deeply interwoven into our routines. These changes are also intricately tied to the survival of small businesses on the platforms, debates over riders' work conditions, and the issue of consumer benefit. This series examines how the upheaval in the delivery market impacts each of these groups and proposes desirable policy designs for the future of the delivery industry.
① Can the issues be solved by focusing only on commission rates?
② Will consumers still use delivery apps without free delivery? Consumer benefits under threat
③ Uniform regulations threatening rider delivery fees... Where will competition for delivery quality end up?
④ With Uber’s entry strengthening monopolies, could public delivery apps serve as an alternative?
As lawmakers begin earnest legislative discussions over regulation of delivery platforms, attention is focusing on the impact for consumers. There is a consensus on the need to ease burdens on small businesses. However, if commission caps lead to reductions in free delivery services and increases in delivery fees, the eventual result may be higher costs for consumers. Consumer advocacy groups have warned of cost transfer, while experts are concerned about a decline in consumer welfare and a possible market contraction.
According to the delivery platform industry on September 28, consumer organizations argue that regulation of commissions on delivery apps could lead to higher food prices or increased delivery fees, ultimately raising consumer costs. The Korea Consumer Federation recently released a statement asserting, “The government should not set delivery prices, but rather ensure fair principles.” The group pointed out, “The delivery market connects platforms, listed vendors, riders, and consumers in a single cost structure. If the burden for one party is artificially reduced, the added costs inevitably shift to others.” They stress that while platform commissions for vendors may decline, consumers could end up paying more for delivery or see higher food prices, and their benefits such as discounts, coupons, and memberships may be reduced as well.
If Free Delivery Disappears, Perceived Costs Rise by 11%
Consumers themselves have expressed concerns about these issues. According to a recent survey by Eunhee Lee, Professor Emeritus of Consumer Science at Inha University, out of 1,000 delivery app users, 7 out of 10 expected their delivery fees to increase if commission caps were implemented. Only 10.8% of respondents expected menu prices to decrease.
Industry sources explain that, as proposed in the current legislation, if total commission fees can no longer exceed 15% of the transaction amount, the burden on listed vendors per order, based on the average order value of 25,000 won, will be less than 4,000 won. Given that riders must be compensated at about 5,000 won per trip, it becomes extremely difficult for delivery services to operate without charging consumers for delivery.
With food prices continually rising, reductions in free delivery along with higher delivery fees are likely to further increase the perceived burden of living expenses for consumers. In Professor Lee’s survey, consumers indicated that if free delivery disappears and a 3,000 won delivery fee is charged, their perceived costs would rise by 11%, causing significant price pressure.
Professor Lee further notes that because free delivery has become the standard by which consumers judge delivery app value, such increased burden is likely to result in fewer orders. She argues that the elimination of free delivery stands to contract the entire market. “Because food prices overall have risen, the total amount consumers pay is already going up, and regulatory changes that further increase consumer burdens will only cause them to order less,” she said, adding, “For one-person households or families with children in particular, where free delivery has become an everyday service, the impact may be even greater.”
Boomerang Effect of a Contracting Delivery Market
Both industry and academia commonly recognize that while commission caps may support small business as intended by policy, they can also bring the side effects of higher consumer costs and a shrinking market. Overseas examples reinforce this. According to research by Zhuoxin Li, a professor at the University of Wisconsin, when 14 cities including New York implemented commission caps, delivery orders fell by an average of 6.8% and net sales at independent restaurants dropped by 3.9%. As a result, New York dramatically relaxed its cap, while San Francisco and the province of British Columbia in Canada repealed the cap altogether.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Experts advise that while easing the burden for small businesses and fostering a fair trade environment are necessary, any institutional change that adjusts specific costs must be considered comprehensively with regard to its impact on the market. Changkeun Lee, a professor at the Graduate School of Entrepreneurship & Business Administration at Chung-Ang University, emphasized, “We need to examine whether regulations shift burdens to other market participants and how they might affect consumer prices, delivery fees, order demand, and service quality.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.