Six Key Issues, Including Site Acquisition, Spark Heated Court Battle
Court Orders Additional Written Statements by the 29th
Decision on Injunction Emerges as Critical Juncture

As a hearing for an injunction to suspend the recommendation decision for candidate universities for a new national medical school in the Jeonnam region takes place, Mokpo National University, the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City, and Suncheon National University remain locked in a tense standoff over the legal nature of the recommendation and the fairness of the evaluation process.


On September 22, the Administrative Division 1 of the Gwangju District Court, presided over by Chief Judge Kim Jeongjoong, held the first hearing on Mokpo National University's application against the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City for a "temporary suspension of the effect of the recommendation decision for candidate universities for a new national medical school."

Students of Mokpo National University hold a "Resolution Rally to Condemn Unfair Screening for Candidate Universities for the Establishment of a National Medical School in the Jeonnam Region" in front of the Gwangju Government Complex in the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City. Provided by Mokpo National University

Students of Mokpo National University hold a "Resolution Rally to Condemn Unfair Screening for Candidate Universities for the Establishment of a National Medical School in the Jeonnam Region" in front of the Gwangju Government Complex in the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City. Provided by Mokpo National University

View original image

The key issues at the hearing included: ▲whether the municipality's recommendation of a candidate university constitutes an administrative disposition ▲the standing of an applicant that failed the evaluation ▲the occurrence of potential damages and urgency ▲the likelihood of winning the main litigation ▲the impact on public welfare ▲and the appropriateness of the evaluation regarding site acquisition.


The Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City argued that "the final authority for selecting the new national medical school rests with the Minister of Education, and the municipality's recommendation is a mere preparatory action, not subject to litigation," consequently calling for dismissal.


On the other hand, Mokpo National University maintained that "exclusion from the municipality's recommendation deprives the university of the opportunity for the Ministry of Education's final review, thereby recognizing both the dispositional nature and urgency of the recommendation act."

Dispute over Interpretation of 'Certainty of Site Acquisition'


One of the core points of contention is the status and feasibility of site acquisition for Suncheon National University's new medical school at the time of evaluation. In its official statement, Mokpo National University pointed out, "Suncheon National University explained on the 17th that 'the site transfer procedure is being carried out in accordance with relevant laws and regulations,' which indicates that site acquisition had not been completed at the time of evaluation."


Mokpo National University argued that, since the evaluation criteria specified the need to confirm the "certainty of site/location acquisition" and the timing of availability, it must be verified whether procedures for transfer of ownership or lawful use, and the necessary budget, were clearly reflected in the schedule for the school's opening in 2030 and the university hospital's opening in 2032.


Furthermore, Mokpo National University asserted that the memorandum of understanding (MOU) and the written confirmation for free site provision executed by Suncheon National University constitute only future commitments, not granting rights to immediate use.


In response, Suncheon National University and the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City countered that they participated in the evaluation process after finalizing an MOU to receive land owned by Suncheon City on a free lease basis, and that the acquisition of site ownership should be determined at the future stage of university establishment approval. The Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City also emphasized that the evaluation phase should respect the professional discretion of the committee members.


There is a significant difference of opinion concerning the results and legitimacy of the evaluators' scoring. According to Mokpo National University, in the "certainty of site/location acquisition" category, 5 out of the total 8 committee members gave identical scores to both universities, while 1 member awarded higher marks to Suncheon National University.


Mokpo National University argued that it is unclear on what grounds sites with differing ownership statuses were evaluated equally or more favorably and noted that Suncheon City only provided its financial support plan response on September 2, after the candidate university review. Therefore, the university claimed that such post-evaluation supplemental documents cannot retroactively justify the earlier evaluation status. Mokpo National University proposed disclosing the submitted plans and conducting an open review by external experts.


In contrast, the respondents maintained that the committee's evaluation was conducted fairly in accordance with the established criteria and submitted data, and that the application of specific evaluation criteria falls within the evaluators' discretionary authority.


The court ordered both sides to submit additional written statements by September 29 and plans to determine whether to grant the request for a provisional injunction after reviewing these documents in early October.



If the court grants the injunction, the process for municipal recommendation of candidate medical schools will be suspended, inevitably disrupting the overall final selection schedule. Conversely, if the request is dismissed or denied, the effect of the municipal recommendation process will be maintained, and discussions on establishing a new national medical school through the Ministry of Education are expected to proceed as planned.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing