[Exclusive] "Is Bureaucratic Discretion Above the Law?" Application Denied at One Word...Will This 68-Year-Old Law Finally Change?
[Regulation Bound NPOs ①] The Approval System for Non-Profit Incorporation
Ministry of Gender Equality and Family to Submit Opinion to Constitutional Court Next Month
Approval Process Lacks Clear Principles and Standards, Enabling Abuse of Discr
Civil Code Article 32, which has remained unchanged since its enactment in 1958, is now one step closer to revision through a constitutional review. Article 32 of the Civil Code stipulates that, for a nonprofit corporation to be established, approval from the relevant supervisory authority must be obtained. Among nonprofit organization (NPO) activists, legal professionals, and academics, this article has long been considered an outdated regulation, ill-suited to modern society. Recently, the government announced that it would submit its opinion on this provision to the Constitutional Court, marking a watershed moment for the ongoing review.
According to the government and the Good Regulation Civil Forum on September 28, the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family—at the time known by that name—rejected approval for the incorporation of “Youth Direct Action,” a youth-based environmental and civic activities group, based on Civil Code Article 32. This decision led to a constitutional review, and after more than six months of delay, the ministry is expected to submit its opinion to the Constitutional Court next month. A representative from the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family stated, “The government has delegated work related to the constitutional review to the Korea Legal Aid Corporation, which plans to submit a draft of the government’s statement to the Constitutional Court in the near future.” Based on statements from both parties, the Constitutional Court will review whether the requirement for governmental approval for the establishment of nonprofit corporations infringes upon the freedom of association, the principle of proportionality, or the principle of equality.
"Excessive State Power—A Request for Constitutional Review"
The case dates back to 2024. At the time, the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family rejected the application to establish a nonprofit incorporated association by Youth Direct Action on multiple occasions, citing reasons such as the business’s office location and financial stability. Even after the group secured additional office space and increased its basic assets to supplement its documents, their application was rejected repeatedly for new reasons over a period of five months. In response, the organization filed an administrative lawsuit, and the Seoul Administrative Court’s bench, which was assigned the case, accepted the plaintiff’s request to refer the law to the Constitutional Court for review and submitted a request for constitutional adjudication. The court determined that there was a need to assess whether the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family had exercised excessive governmental authority, and formally sought the Constitutional Court’s decision.
The review process proceeded slowly. In February of this year, the Korea Legal Aid Corporation requested an extension for the deadline for submitting the government’s opinion. In March, Pacific Law (Bae, Kim & Lee LLC), acting as legal representative for the group, submitted its opinion, but the government’s response had yet to be submitted, leaving the process at a virtual standstill. However, with the ministry’s announcement—through the Korea Legal Aid Corporation—that it would submit its statement in the near future, the decision by the Constitutional Court is expected to speed up. The case has drawn considerable attention in legal circles, as more than 10 leading law firms—including Pacific Law, Sejong, Barun, Jipyong, Gwangjang, and Yulchon—are jointly responding to it.
Last month, there was also a case in which the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism lost the first trial in an administrative suit regarding its rejection of incorporation for “Planet Resident Center,” a group promoting social trips combining local volunteering and travel, and programs supporting marginalized communities. The ministry had rejected the application due to insufficient operational capacity and incomplete documents. However, the Seoul Administrative Court canceled the rejection, citing abuse of discretion—especially because the applicant had not been given an opportunity to supplement the required paperwork.
"Supervisor Law Above Statute"... The Unending Game of Passing Responsibility
Article 32 of the Civil Code stipulates that “an association or foundation established for academic, religious, charitable, artistic, social, or other non-profit purposes may acquire corporate status upon approval from the relevant supervising authority.” As the law contains no other procedures or criteria except for approval, in practice, decisions about the establishment of nonprofit corporations are largely left to the discretion of public officials at the governmental or local level. In reality, this is often considered a routine administrative task entrusted even to low-ranking officials within each department. Cases are not uncommon where the granting official lacks the necessary expertise in nonprofit operations and denies approval out of concern for potential future accountability issues.
Bang Daewook, head of the Daum Foundation, which supports nonprofit startups, said, “We applied to a local government for permission to convert a social enterprise helping elderly people who collect recyclable materials into a nonprofit incorporated association but were rejected four times. When we submitted the same documents to the Ministry of Budget and Planning (then the Ministry of Strategy and Finance), we received approval within two months.” He remarked, “Because the outcome depends on how the supervisory official interprets the case, people jokingly say that there is a ‘supervisory law above the statute.’ Ministries continue to pass responsibility back and forth, claiming the matter is outside their jurisdiction. Ultimately, work is deferred to the weakest department, or when a supervisory official is replaced, approval standards revert to square one—with this cycle repeating constantly.”
The structure forcing nonprofit groups, tasked with addressing complex, multi-ministerial social issues, to seek approval from only one particular ministry has also been highlighted as a problem. For example, a group seeking incorporation to promote improved transport policy and disability rights was told by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport that “issues concerning people with disabilities fall under the responsibility of the Ministry of Health and Welfare.” When the group subsequently applied to the Ministry of Health and Welfare, it was told, “Transport policies are the business of the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport,” leading to an endless game of passing responsibility. Park Dongsun, director of the National YWCA of Korea, pointed out, “Even when trying to pursue integrated public interest projects, there are cases where, in order to satisfy ministerial administrative boundaries and obtain supervisory approval, organizations must eliminate or scale back entire projects—an absurd situation.”
For-Profit Corporations Allowed, But Not Nonprofits?
A disparity in treatment between for-profit and nonprofit corporations also exists. Any for-profit company can be established freely as long as legal requirements are met. Notably, with the 2009 amendment to the Commercial Act, the minimum capital requirement was abolished, allowing, in theory, a stock corporation to be established with as little as 100 won. The government lowered the entry barrier so that anyone with an idea could start a business.
On the other hand, nonprofit corporations seeking to create public and social value face high entry barriers because of the approval requirement from the start. Even though the Civil Code does not specify a minimum capital requirement, regulatory ministries often impose a customary demand for contributions amounting to tens of millions of won in basic assets, depending on the department. This imposes a much higher financial burden on charitable, academic, and civic groups—those operating without profit—compared to for-profit companies.
The same issue is present in the system governing the merger and division of corporations. The Commercial Act allows for-profit companies to flexibly pursue mergers and acquisitions (M&A) and demergers, adapting to changes in the business environment and enhancing management efficiency. There are also safeguards in place to prevent unnecessary tax burdens or other losses for shareholders and companies during their restructuring processes.
In contrast, nonprofit corporations have no legal provisions regarding mergers or splits, so they must dissolve and liquidate existing entities and then establish new ones. Satisfying the interests of stakeholders, including corporate creditors, in this process is not easy. Administrative and financial losses also mount as organizations have to repeat the incorporation approval process. The National YWCA of Korea experienced the burden of double taxation while separating local chapters as independent legal entities.
Additionally, for-profit companies can complete changes in their organizational structure by simply preparing resolutions at shareholder meetings or board meetings and registering them at the registry office. For nonprofit corporations, even simple matters such as changing addresses, amending the articles of association, or disposing of basic property all require explicit approval from the supervisory ministry for the decision to take effect.
"We Need to Scrap the Approval Requirement and Adopt the Rule-Based Principle"
There are increasingly louder calls for a fundamental transition in laws and systems to enable the nonprofit sector to solve complex social problems flexibly. Regulations around nonprofit incorporation can be classified into four categories: approval (permission) principle, licensing principle, rule-based principle, and free establishment principle. Experts stress the transition to a rule-based principle, which would allow registration and incorporation without the approval of a supervisory authority as long as certain statutory requirements are met. They point out that the licensing principle leaves considerable room for government discretion, and if the licensing power is exercised like a permission power, any shift to that system becomes meaningless.
The permission-based approach in Article 32 of the Civil Code, which was adopted almost directly from the Japanese Civil Code, has been in place since 1960—a period of 66 years. Although the Ministry of Justice has proposed amendments to the Civil Code repeatedly, they all eventually lapsed with the expiration of each National Assembly’s term. The effectiveness of these amendments, too, was questioned: the revisions proposed in 2004, 2011, and 2014 were all aimed at converting the approval principle into the licensing principle. At that time, concerns over a glut of nonprofit groups led to the choice of the licensing principle. However, even Japan—after many years of utilizing the approval principle—shifted to a rule-based system in 2008, and major countries such as the United States and the United Kingdom have also adopted rule-based approaches. Today, only China, Russia, and a few Southeast Asian nations still require permission for the establishment of nonprofit incorporated associations.
Lee Dongjin, professor at Seoul National University School of Law, stated, “The licensing principle excludes the administrative agency’s discretion, but, in essence, it’s a variant of the approval principle; changing permission to licensing does not substantially change the system.” Kim Kyungmok, attorney at Pacific Law, emphasized, “Public interest activities have played critical roles in civic society by monitoring both the state and the market and proposing policy alternatives. It is an anachronistic notion to perpetuate outdated regulations out of fear of nonprofit proliferation, when societal conditions have clearly shifted since the 1960s, when the Civil Code was first introduced.”
Chung Jingyeong, professor of public administration at Kwangwoon University and head of the Nonprofit Regulation Task Force at the Good Regulation Civil Forum, remarked, “Nonprofit and public interest corporations are playing an increasingly important complementary role in government policy, and their potential is only growing. Now is the time for a deliberate national strategy to maximize their impact.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.