Challenges in Establishing Independent Legal Status for Korea YWCA Branches
Burdened by Discretionary Rules and Double Taxation
"Legal and Administrative Systems Must Move Beyond Regulation-Centric Practices"

Dongsun Park, Director of Korea YWCA Federation

Dongsun Park, Director of Korea YWCA Federation

View original image

The Korea YWCA Federation is a leading civic organization in Korea, established in 1922 by Christian women active in the independence movement. It has served as a foundational pillar of Korea’s nonprofit ecosystem. However, even the Korea YWCA, with its 100-year history, has faced considerable challenges due to the requirements surrounding incorporation approvals and the excessive discretionary authority wielded by supervisory authorities. Numerous issues surfaced during the process of converting 50 local branches—each rooted in and serving their community—into independent legal entities and transferring assets to them.


Dongsun Park, Director of Korea YWCA Federation, recently described in an interview with The Asia Business Daily the difficulties faced while establishing 50 local branches as independent incorporated associations. This initiative was launched ahead of the organization’s 100th anniversary in 2022 to increase transparency and operational efficiency, as well as to allow each branch to focus more effectively on addressing local issues through public interest activities. It was a sweeping organizational overhaul, involving the transfer of all facilities and institutions managed by the branches from the central corporate body to each branch’s legal entity.


The first major obstacle was financial. The criteria for required basic assets to operate a corporation were unclear, creating confusion as each local government stipulated different amounts. One municipality (A) initially stated that the minimum asset requirement was zero, but later changed its demand to 50 million won to match a neighboring region’s standard. In another case, after a personnel change, municipality B increased its previously agreed minimum asset requirement from 30 million won to 50 million won. Director Park explained, "Unlike foundations, which are aggregations of property, incorporated associations are essentially bodies of people, so there is no legal basis for imposing a minimum asset requirement." She added, "Other than the stipulation that nonprofit corporations must obtain approval from a supervisory authority, there are no clear regulations. It felt as though the discretionary power of officials trumped the law itself."

[Regulation-Bound NPO②] Even a Century-Old Organization Faced High Barriers with the Permit-Based System View original image

Even within a single municipality, turf wars between departments persisted for months, with divisions passing off responsibility because the scope of nonprofit activities—such as women’s issues, welfare, and education—was so broad. In one case (municipality C), the branch was even told it needed approval from all ten relevant departments because its work spanned multiple sectors. Even after painstakingly obtaining the incorporation certificate, procedures stalled at the registry office and the tax office, where officials, lacking understanding of nonprofit law, questioned why such corporations engaged in revenue-generating activities and demanded amendments to the organization’s articles of association. Director Park recounted, "Once we receive the certificate of incorporation, we must complete company registration at the registry office within three weeks, and file a nonprofit business registration at the tax office within two months. However, additional documentation and demands for bylaw revisions continuously left us feeling burned out."


Asset transfer also proved a significant challenge. Despite taxes already having been paid when the original assets were acquired, local YWCAs were charged additional acquisition and registration taxes simply because the assets were being moved to a new legal entity. The organization also discovered that protective facilities for domestic violence survivors—run by local YWCAs under the authority of the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family (then the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family)—were not covered by local tax exemptions as stipulated in the Restriction of Special Local Taxation Act. After a nationwide signature drive and calls for legislative reform, the government and lawmakers finally recognized the issue, relieving some tax burdens. However, since the new branches were categorized as new legal entities, all previous project records, performance outcomes, and long-term staff tenure of the local YWCAs were reset to zero. As a result, their competitiveness in government project bids decreased, and their operational capacity was underestimated.


The two- to three-year restructuring of the Korea YWCA Federation ultimately became a case study of how Korea’s nonprofit corporation system is mired in unnecessary regulations, restrictions, and vague guidelines.



On September 30, Korea YWCA Federation will hold a regional forum in Busan to share these on-the-ground experiences and raise questions about reforming Korea’s permit-based civil law system that has persisted for nearly 70 years. In November, a follow-up forum will be held in Suwon to broaden the nationwide discussion about the unconstitutionality and structural issues of Article 32 of the Civil Code. Director Park emphasized, "It is time to overhaul the legal, institutional, and administrative procedures related to nonprofit corporations—moving away from a regulatory mindset to one that fosters civic participation and encourages the public interest."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing