"Freedom of expression must be fully protected"

The Supreme Court has ruled that expressions labeling someone as homosexual may constitute defamation by stating a fact, depending on the context or intent. However, if such statements are made for the public interest, the unlawfulness may be negated.

Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on September 22, the Supreme Court's First Division (Presiding Justice Cheon Dae-yeop) recently upheld an appellate court's acquittal of defendant A, who was charged with defamation.


In August 2021, A was indicted for implying that B, the head of a civic group and politician, was a homosexual by posting on a personal blog: "A 'butch' in a lesbian relationship takes the male role and, therefore, views all men as adversaries."


The trial court found A guilty and fined them 3 million won. The court held that even though B had come out as homosexual, this pertains to a private sphere, and B's sexual orientation could not be considered a matter of public concern for the general public.


In contrast, the appellate court acquitted A, determining that the word "lesbian" is a value-neutral term denoting sexual identity. Additionally, considering that B is engaged in social activities urging improvement by highlighting the distortion of sexual norms among certain members of society, the court found that criticism of B's own sexual views must be tolerated. Therefore, the statement served the public interest, and the action was not deemed unlawful.


However, the Supreme Court still recognized that A's statement constituted the specification of facts that harmed another person's reputation. The court stated, "There are still negative perceptions and prejudices about homosexuality in our society," and added, "Publicly declaring someone's homosexuality, with the intent to demean their dignity or reputation, depending on the nature, method, and context of the statement, can infringe on social value and evaluation."


The court continued, "Even if the victim had previously disclosed their sexual orientation within an organization, revealing one's intimate sexual orientation in a safe and trusted space by choice is fundamentally different from being publicly outed by another individual."



However, the Supreme Court concluded that A's statement pertained to the public interest and therefore was not unlawful. This was because B, as a politician engaged in public activities, is subject to scrutiny and criticism. Furthermore, the court indicated that freedom of expression must be guaranteed to the fullest extent possible in a democratic nation, making punishment difficult in this instance.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing