"Unable to Find Specific Reasons or Constitutional Grounds"
Conflict Over Supreme Court Justice Appointment Likely to Prolong

Cho Hee-dae, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, has officially rejected the presidential office's request to re-nominate a Supreme Court justice candidate. This move comes 25 days after the presidential office requested the re-nomination. The conflict between the two sides over the selection of Supreme Court justices has resurfaced.


Cho Hee-dae, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. Photo by Yonhap News

Cho Hee-dae, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

On September 22, Chief Justice Cho said, "I cannot comply with the request for re-nomination this time." He cited the constitutional procedures required for the President's official acts. Chief Justice Cho stated, "The President's official acts must be made through documents countersigned by the Prime Minister and the relevant ministers," and added, "In relation to this request for re-nomination, there is only the 'Request for Re-nomination of Supreme Court Justice Candidate' dated August 28." He continued, "This document does not state the specific reasons for requesting a re-nomination or the constitutional basis for it," and emphasized, "I could not find any other specific constitutional grounds or reasons that would justify the request for re-nomination."


With Chief Justice Cho making it clear that he will not accept the presidential office's demand for a re-nomination, the conflict over the selection of Supreme Court justices is likely to become prolonged. Previously, on August 18, Chief Justice Cho recommended Son Bong-gi, chief judge of the Daegu District Court, to President Lee Jaemyung as the successor to former Supreme Court Justice Noh Tae-ak. However, the presidential office did not submit Son's confirmation motion to the National Assembly and instead, on August 28, requested that Chief Justice Cho re-nominate another candidate. The presidential office argued at the time that the nomination of Son had been made without substantive consultation between the President and the Chief Justice. The presidential office maintained the position that the Chief Justice's nomination authority should be exercised in a way that respects the President's actual appointment power.



On the other hand, Chief Justice Cho raised questions about the constitutional basis for the very request for a re-nomination. The reasoning also appears to be based on the fact that there is no explicit provision requiring another nomination if the President does not accept the Chief Justice's nomination. Article 104 of the Constitution stipulates that Supreme Court justices are to be appointed by the President with the consent of the National Assembly, based on the recommendation of the Chief Justice. However, the Constitution does not specify whether the Chief Justice must re-nominate, or what procedure should be followed, if the President does not proceed with the appointment process for a nominated candidate.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing