Providing User Data to Calculate NSF Scores for Apple’s Consolidated Billing
Focus on Whose Work and Interests Were Served
No Valid Consent for International Transfer or Use in NSF Scoring

"Kakao Pay did not even know how the NSF score (a customer-specific score used to assess the risk of insufficient funds) was generated or where it was being used. The key legal question was whether these activities could truly be considered as 'outsourced processing'—in other words, whether Kakao Pay had truly delegated this work."


Jin Hyuk Choi, an attorney at Barun Law Firm, explained the core issues in an interview with The Asia Business Daily on September 23, 2026 regarding the lawsuit in which Barun represented the Personal Information Protection Commission (PIPC) and secured a victory against Kakao Pay’s challenge to PIPC’s corrective action orders. Kakao Pay had provided user data—including email addresses, mobile phone numbers, account balances, top-up records, payment and transfer counts—to Alipay, in order to calculate the NSF score required for Apple’s consolidated payment services. The PIPC regarded this as a provision of personal data to a third party overseas without user consent, imposed an administrative fine of 5.968 billion won, and issued corrective and public notice orders. The court upheld the PIPC’s sanctions as justified.

Attorney Jinhyuk Choi from Barun Law Firm is posing. Photo by Dongju Yoon

Attorney Jinhyuk Choi from Barun Law Firm is posing. Photo by Dongju Yoon

View original image

◆Establishing ‘Third Party Provision’ Over ‘Outsourced Processing’

The outcome of the lawsuit hinged on whether the information transferred from Kakao Pay to Alipay constituted 'outsourced processing,' or if it should be classified as 'provision to a third party' requiring user consent. Kakao Pay argued that Alipay was tasked with work to help prevent fraudulent payments. Barun Law Firm focused on determining whose work and benefit the personal information actually served.


The NSF score was used by Apple to determine whether to process billing as single transactions or batch them. Attorney Choi explained, "We emphasized to the court that it’s difficult to view a product as your own work if you don’t even know how it is created," adding, "It was an important circumstance demonstrating that the information was provided for Apple's work, not Kakao Pay's."


Another key issue was Kakao Pay's prior consent collection from users for customer identification, identity verification, and billing purposes. Barun Law Firm argued that such consents alone could not be deemed as user consent for telecommunication of data overseas nor for the use of information in the NSF scoring system.

◆Framing Personal Data and NSF Score as a ‘Single Process’

A further point of contention was whether to treat the original personal data handed over by Kakao Pay and the resulting NSF score as separate information. Barun Law Firm maintained that, even though the two kinds of data are different in form, since the personal information was provided solely for the calculation of NSF scores, they should be considered a single process when determining their intended purpose, interests served, and control. The court agreed with this reasoning.


In the final arguments, Barun Law Firm visually illustrated the path of personal data using diagrams and PowerPoint slides. While the data physically traveled from Kakao Pay to Alipay, they explained that, from a legal perspective, Kakao Pay had provided the data to Apple, with Alipay (as Apple’s entrusted processor) processing it on Apple’s behalf. Attorney Choi’s decade of experience as a software developer contributed to connecting these technical structures with legal logic.



The court found that over approximately five years, Kakao Pay had transferred the personal data of about 40 million users to overseas entities on a daily basis and that the cumulative volume of information reached 54.2 billion records, thereby infringing on the data subjects’ right to informational self-determination and control. Attorney Choi commented, "This decision is significant because it clarifies that the determination between outsourcing and provision to a third party should be based on the actual purposes, attribution of benefits, and control—not just formalities."

Barun Defends 4,000 Million Kakao Pay Users' Data Case: Overturning ‘Simple Outsourcing’ Claims and Upholding 5.968 Billion Won Fine Against Alipay [Winning Design] View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing