Enforcement Ordinance of the Amended Franchise Act
Aimed at Targeting Major Brands While Overlooking Market Realities
Requirements for Registration Should Be Lowered, but Negotiation Channel Must Be Unified

[Inside Chodong] Enforcement Ordinance of the Franchise Business Act Fuels Conflict View original image

Korea's franchise industry has a long history of power abuses. There have been frequent conflicts between headquarters and franchisees over issues such as the forced purchase of raw materials at prices higher than the market rate, demands for repeated interior renovations, and the opening of new stores in close proximity. Last year, it was revealed that Myeongryun-dang, the operator of Myeongryun Jinsa Galbi, borrowed policy funds at low interest rates and lent them to franchisees at high interest rates. The Fair Transactions in Franchise Business Act was enacted and has been amended several times to prevent such power abuses by franchisors, and starting from December this year, it will grant franchisees the right to form organizations similar to labor unions.


Franchisees occupy a dual position in that they are both business owners, providing salaries to employees, and at the same time subject to the control of franchisors, working long hours. As it is virtually impossible for them to respond individually to unfair contract terms, granting franchisees the right to collective organization to strengthen their negotiating power is justified.


The issue lies with the implementing ordinance of this law. The ordinance, announced by the Fair Trade Commission on September 14, stipulates that a franchisee association can be registered if more than 10% of all franchisees using the same brand, or at least 1,000 franchisees, join. Additionally, there is a minimum requirement of 30 members for registration. As of the end of last year, the number of franchise brands registered with the Fair Trade Commission stood at 13,725, with 74.4% being small-scale brands with fewer than 10 franchisees. Large-scale brands with more than 100 franchisees accounted for only 3.6%.


Originally, the franchise industry argued that more than 50% of all franchisees should be required for collective registration, while the Fair Trade Commission insisted on a threshold of 30%. However, the ordinance abruptly lowered this to 10%. Additionally, a provision was introduced allowing associations of at least 1,000 franchisees, primarily to lower the registration barrier for the convenience store industry, which has around 18,000 franchisees. While this reflected the viewpoint of franchisees who, due to the busy nature of self-employment, may have lower rates of association, the ordinance was made without fully accounting for the reality that an overwhelming majority of franchises consist of small-scale brands.


If enforced as is, most franchisees belonging to small-scale brands will not be able to register associations. For BGF Retail, which holds the top position in terms of number of convenience stores, up to 18 franchisee associations could be permitted. In a worst-case scenario, this means the headquarters could face as many as 18 separate negotiating entities representing franchisees. If each of these associations frequently requests negotiations or if their positions differ, it may be difficult to coordinate effective discussions.


Furthermore, the ordinance allows franchisee associations to have representatives attend negotiations with headquarters. Since information asymmetry is inevitable for franchisees, assistance from franchise business experts could be essential. However, the ordinance does not limit who may act as a representative, so not only franchisee councils but also civic or labor organizations—who may lack professional expertise—can negotiate on behalf of franchisees. Headquarters have deep distrust toward these outside organizations. Thus, the law designed to resolve conflicts between headquarters and franchisees may end up provoking more conflict.



Labor law, which allows for multiple unions, at least unified the bargaining channel to reduce unnecessary disputes. The Fair Transactions in Franchise Business Act should also lower the threshold for registering franchisee associations, but at the same time unify the negotiation channel and restrict representatives to attorneys or certified franchise specialists.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing