Clash Between a Laid-off Working-class Couple and an Upper-class Couple

The Pain of Others Before the Camera: Questioning the Ethics of the Creator

Still cut from the movie 'Possible Love'.

Still cut from the movie 'Possible Love'.

View original image

※ This article contains numerous spoilers from the film.


How does the violence of capital violate human dignity? Can art that observes the tragedy of others ever be considered ethical? Director Lee Chang-dong's newest film 'Possible Love' directly confronts these two questions. It tells the story of two couples: laborers Hoseok (Sol Kyung-gu) and Miok (Jeon Do-yeon), whose lives collapse after mass layoffs, and upper-class couple Sangwoo (Jo In-sung) and Yeji (Cho Yeo-jeong), who attempt to document their suffering in a documentary. The film interrogates the contradictions of contemporary society on three levels: the collapse of dismissed workers, class conflict where horizontal solidarity is impossible, and creative ethics that exploit their subjects.


Layoffs: The Collapse of Labor and Survival


The turning point of Hoseok's downfall is a factory occupation strike. The protest site, which the workers considered their own 'liberated zone,' is decimated by the intervention of police special forces. As Hoseok is trampled under riot shields and boots on the rooftop, his young colleagues and fellow workers flee, leaving him behind. As they depart, his faith in humanity disappears along with them.


Still cut from the movie 'Possible Love'.

Still cut from the movie 'Possible Love'.

View original image

The so-called restructuring divides workers into the 'living' and the 'dead.' Hoseok, after being laid off, tails a younger colleague who has returned to ordinary life, watching him buy a birthday cake for his child, and comes to see himself as an empty ghost. This psychological destruction becomes starkly apparent in a group therapy session for laid-off workers and their families. Hoseok's wife—suppressing her breathing like a criminal in the elevator out of fear she might meet a neighbor who still works at the company—and a colleague who confesses to having forced a laugh at being called a 'commie,' only to choke on indignation, exemplify the collective trauma.


Such traces also remain at home. The marble bench that Hoseok built before the strike, to grill pork belly with his coworkers, is now only a place where laundry is hung. In the meantime, words like 'struggle' and 'solidarity' have been dismissed as nonsense. Capital power not only cuts off livelihoods but also fosters hatred and isolation among workers themselves.


Class Conflict: Disconnected Worlds and the Hypocrisy of Capitalists


The film places the observing capitalists and the observed workers in the same space, exposing the violence and disparities between the two classes. Sangwoo represents the privileged class that has inherited vast wealth. The whistle used by Sangwoo's grandfather, who was a police officer during the Japanese colonial era, serves as a central metaphor for the inherited violence of both financial capital and government authority. Minshik, the caretaker of their villa, still bows his head at the sound of the whistle. In this image, vertical class structure is shown as an ongoing reality.


Still cut from the movie 'Possible Love'.

Still cut from the movie 'Possible Love'.

View original image

Sangwoo's lavish villa becomes the setting for clashes between the two classes. In a drunken state, Hoseok urinates all over Sangwoo's stylish bathroom. This is the only form of resistance available to someone at the bottom who has lost everything. Sangwoo, rather than reacting with anger, simply laughs and urinates on the floor with him, turning Hoseok's act of defiance into the wealthy man's game. This difference is also revealed in the way both men work: Hoseok toils in fear of death, while Sangwoo can strike a jackpot with only a few clicks on his laptop.


On the beach, Sangwoo uses the guise of freedom to approach Miok while she swims naked, demonstrating violence that asserts his power. Miok, retreating and covering herself with her clothes, shows how powerless the lower class is in the face of capital dominance. In the villa’s underground home bar, Miok sings a sultry song while Sangwoo plays the clarinet, and Hoseok dances absentmindedly. This scene, observed by their son Cheol-i, is closer to discord than harmony.


Creative Ethics: The Tangle of Communication and the Camera’s Violence


Director Lee questions the ethics of creators through Yeji’s camera. Yeji secures a production grant by promising judges that she will capture the real value of labor through its specific realities. Yet, on set, she manipulates and dramatizes the subjects' pain. For example, she encourages Miok to recount memories of her impoverished and wounded childhood, then claps the slate and asks her to reenact it, as if for the first time. When Miok produces Hoseok’s old employee badge from a major corporation, Yeji even requests a zoom-in shot. At an elementary school sports day, she tries to film Cheol-i, who cannot keep up with his classmates. To this, Sangwoo remarks, "You're method acting to love the workers."


Still cut from the movie 'Possible Love'.

Still cut from the movie 'Possible Love'.

View original image

Even when Hoseok is in danger, Yeji’s camera does not turn off. In the deep of night, in a stream near the villa, Hoseok has a seizure. Rather than helping, Yeji hides behind a tree, intent on filming. Even in a situation where someone's life is at risk, her only focus is on getting ‘good footage.’ When the Miok couple leaves the villa, Yeji pesters them about the missing whistle. The attitude of solidarity with the underclass, professed by those who intervene in their lives, evaporates the moment her own property is in question. The tangle of communication, it turns out, never existed in the first place.



‘Possible Love’ allows no room for romantic redemption, contrary to what the title might suggest. In the final scene, the sound of son Cheol-i blowing the whistle he had stolen and run off with is like a declaration—a theft of inherited power from capital, turning it into the voice of the underclass. But reality remains unchanged. That is why ‘possible’ in the title must be read not as a statement of possibility, but as a question.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing