Park Ansu Sentenced to 10 Years, Gwak Jonggeun to 9 Years, Moon Sangho to 12 Years

Lee Jinwoo, Park Ansu, and Gwak Jonggeun Ordered Back to Detention After Bail Release

Ye In-hyung, former Commander of the ROK Armed Forces Counterintelligence Command, and Lee Jin-woo, former Commander of the ROK Capital Defense Command, who were brought to trial on charges including the deployment of troops to the National Assembly and the National Election Commission during the 12·3 martial law, have been sentenced to 18 years and 15 years in prison, respectively, at the first trial.

Ye In-hyung, former head of the Military Counterintelligence Command, is speaking as a witness at the 5th hearing of President Yoon Suk-yeol's impeachment trial held at the Constitutional Court in Jongno-gu, Seoul, on February 4 last year. Photo by Yonhap News

Ye In-hyung, former head of the Military Counterintelligence Command, is speaking as a witness at the 5th hearing of President Yoon Suk-yeol's impeachment trial held at the Constitutional Court in Jongno-gu, Seoul, on February 4 last year. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

On September 21, the Seoul Central District Court Criminal Division 26 (Presiding Judge Lee Hyunkyung) sentenced former Commander Ye to 18 years in prison and former Commander Lee to 15 years in prison on charges including participating in a major mission related to an insurrection and abuse of power. Park An-su, former Army Chief of Staff (and at that time Martial Law Commander), who was also indicted, was sentenced to 10 years, Gwak Jong-geun, former Special Warfare Command Commander, to 9 years, and Moon Sang-ho, former Commander of the Defense Intelligence Command, to 12 years. The court also found former Commander Ye guilty of additional charges of perjury.


The court ordered the re-detention of former Commander Lee, former Chief of Staff Park, and former Commander Gwak, who had been on trial after release on bail. Former Commander Ye and former Commander Moon are already being held in custody.


Previously, at the sentencing hearing held in July, the special prosecutor team had sought 30 years each for former Commander Ye and former Commander Lee, 25 years for former Chief of Staff Park, and 20 years each for former Commander Gwak and former Commander Moon.


The court established that former President Yoon Suk-yeol and former Minister of National Defense Kim Yonghyun aimed to incapacitate the National Assembly, and, based on unconstitutional and illegal proclamations, attempted to arrest and detain key figures without warrants. The court added that martial law was declared with the intention of making it impossible for the National Assembly and the Election Commission to exercise their authority. The court ruled that this amounted to an uprising with the intent of overturning the constitutional order, and those defendants who participated in key roles during the insurrection should be punished for their involvement in major missions related to the insurrection. Except for former Commander Gwak, who admitted all charges, the other four claimed they had no intent to overthrow the constitutional order or to participate in an insurrection, but the court rejected these arguments.


The court found, based on former Commander Ye's notes, that he had several meetings with former President Yoon and former Minister Kim, during which he heard about their intention to impose martial law, and that he was aware that such a measure would not be justified in peacetime. In the notes written by former Commander Ye himself, phrases such as "priority arrest and search for proclamation violations," "joint military, prosecutorial, and police investigations," "list of major figures," "operation of joint arrest teams," and "securing evidence at the Election Commission" were included. The court considered these notes to correspond closely with the actual martial law operations, and judged that former Commander Ye wrote them after discussions with former President Yoon and Minister Kim, stating, "It is recognized that there was active premeditation."


The court also convicted former Commander Ye on all perjury charges. He had testified that he had never instructed the 1st Director of the Counterintelligence Command to secure the Election Commission’s server, nor had he told the Chief of Police that intelligence personnel would enter the Election Commission. However, the court found the statements of the 1st Director and Chief of Police to be detailed and consistent, thus credible.


Regarding former Commander Lee, the court pointed to notes written before the martial law, which included "public address to the nation," "issue crowbars, hammers, blanks to individuals," and "pre-deployment of counterterrorism units." Although former Commander Lee argued that his notes were contingency plans under the Framework Act on Integrated Defense, the court judged that their contents closely matched the sequence of President Yoon’s proclamation and martial law declaration, and did not align with the intent of the Integrated Defense Act.


The court also recognized that former Commander Lee, just before the vote to lift martial law, was directed by former President Yoon to "pull out lawmakers from the Assembly," and relayed similar orders to his subordinates. The testimony of his aide-de-camp, who overheard the conversation, matched that of other unit members, supporting this conclusion.


As Martial Law Commander, former Chief of Staff Park called the Chief of Police, informed him of the issuance of the proclamation, and requested that access to the National Assembly be blocked. This resulted in a second blockade of the National Assembly, which was found to be a criminal act. Former Chief of Staff Park claimed he was acting under duress and misunderstood the law, but the court did not accept this argument. The court stated, "It appears that, upon receiving the proclamation, there was a need for legal review, but there is no evidence that such review was conducted." However, the court acquitted former Chief of Staff Park on charges of abuse of power relating to deploying the Capital Defense Command and Special Warfare Command, as conspiracy on this point was not proven.


Former Commander Moon was found guilty of learning of election fraud suspicions from Noh Sangwon, former Director of the Intelligence Command, and, immediately after the martial law declaration, sending intelligence agents into the Election Commission. The court found that former Commander Moon should have recognized that detaining Election Commission employees and seizing server data would effectively prevent the Election Commission, a constitutional body, from exercising its authority.


For sentencing, the court said, "To make it impossible for a constitutional body to exercise its authority can never be justified under any circumstances," and added, "The defendants abandoned the military's mission, duties, and political neutrality, and used military force for the political interests of a particular group."


Regarding former Commander Ye, the court pointed out that he denied having ordered his subordinate to secure the Election Commission’s server, committed perjury, and tried to shift responsibility. The court also explained that the fact that the order was not actually carried out was due to passive responses from unit members and resistance from citizens, which was not considered as a favorable circumstance. Former Commander Lee was also found to have shifted responsibility onto his subordinate by denying the order to remove lawmakers from the Assembly. However, the fact that he instructed Capital Defense Command troops to remain unarmed and did not use physical force was considered as a partially favorable circumstance.



Former Chief of Staff Park was found not to have taken part in advance discussions with former President Yoon and Minister Kim before the martial law, and the court considered the fact that he prevented the use of tasers and blanks by the Special Warfare Command as a favorable point. Former Commander Gwak was noted for having played the most critical role in preventing the parliamentary decision to lift martial law, having received orders from Minister Kim to deploy troops to the National Assembly, Election Commission, Democratic Party headquarters, and polling organizations. However, his early confession and consistent statements throughout the process were taken into account, leading to a mandatory sentence reduction under the Special Prosecution Act.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing