The Supreme Court of Korea has ruled that a worker diagnosed with pneumoconiosis can receive a disaster relief payment, even if they did not receive or apply for medical care benefits at the time the mine was closed, as long as they received a disability grade determination after the closure.


On September 3, 2026, the Supreme Court’s Special First Division (Presiding Justice Seo Kyunhwan) overturned the prior judgment that had ruled against the bereaved family of mine worker A, who had filed a lawsuit against Korea Mine Rehabilitation and Mineral Resources Corporation seeking a disaster relief payment (2025Du34997), and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court. Attorney Park Sungmin (1st Bar Exam) of People & Smart Law Office and others represented the bereaved family.


The disaster relief payment is a sum provided separately from industrial accident compensation, as part of measures to support the livelihood stability of workers affected by mine closures.


[Facts of the Case]

Mr. A was diagnosed with pneumoconiosis in 1994 while working at a coal mine. He subsequently worked at another mine, which ceased operations in 2009. In 2003, Mr. A received a Grade 13 disability determination, and after the closure, his condition worsened, resulting in a grade progression to 11 in 2013 and then to 7 in 2015. After Mr. A’s death in 2017, his family claimed approximately 91.27 million won as disaster relief payment and additional delayed damages, based on the final Grade 7 disability assessment.


The main issue at trial was whether disaster relief payments under the former Enforcement Decree of the Coal Industry Act could be made, even if the person had not received or applied for medical care benefits under the Industrial Accident Insurance Act at the time of the mine closure.


[Lower Court Rulings]

The first instance court dismissed the family’s claim, reasoning there was no evidence that Mr. A received or applied for medical care benefits at the time of the mine closure, which the former Enforcement Decree of the Coal Industry Act required for payment eligibility.


The appeals court also dismissed the family’s appeal, holding that pneumoconiosis screening and transportation cost compensation for early detection and prevention are different from medical care benefits provided for treatment purposes.


[Supreme Court Decision (Summary)]

- Pneumoconiosis can progress even after leaving a workplace where dust is present, and it is difficult to predict the rate of progression. This is a disease where disability benefits may be received even without medical care benefits.


- If a worker was diagnosed with pneumoconiosis before the mine closed and received a worsening disability assessment after closure, they fall under the category eligible for disaster relief payments under the former Enforcement Decree of the Coal Industry Act, regardless of whether they received or applied for medical care benefits at the time of the closure.


- Whether complications arise before or after the mine closure is incidental, depending on the disease’s progression. Excluding someone from eligibility based on timing lacks reasonable basis and violates the constitutional principle of equality.



Reporter: Sangwoo Lee, The Law Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing