U.S. Department of Commerce Introduces New Statistical Method
Challenge Dismissed, Ending a Decade of Efforts

The U.S. court has recognized the U.S. Department of Commerce's newly introduced "2% price difference standard" in the process of calculating anti-dumping duties.


On September 15, 2026 (local time), the U.S. Court of International Trade (CIT) ruled that the "2% price difference standard" is reasonable in the anti-dumping investigation concerning welded line pipe from South Korea, upholding the Department of Commerce’s fourth remand determination (26-113). SeAH Steel, which has been contesting the anti-dumping duty calculation method for over a decade, lost the case this time.

SeAH Steel Logo.

SeAH Steel Logo.

View original image

The case began in 2014 with an anti-dumping investigation into welded line pipe from South Korea. The following year, the Department of Commerce calculated a dumping margin of 2.53% for SeAH Steel. In the process, the Department analyzed price differences by customer, region, and period using "Cohen's d," a statistical measure of the difference between two groups’ means. According to this standard, 39.72% of SeAH Steel’s sales in the U.S. were found to show a "significant price difference."


SeAH Steel filed a lawsuit, claiming that the U.S. sales price data did not meet the conditions necessary to apply Cohen's d. The case went back and forth multiple times between the CIT and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC), and the CAFC ordered the Department to reanalyze price differences in 2025 without using Cohen’s d.


In response, the Department introduced the new "2% price difference standard." Under this rule, there is deemed to be a "significant price difference" if the average selling price of the same product to a specific customer differs by 2% or more from the average price to other customers. For example, if the average price to customer A is 100 won and the average to all other customers is 103 won, this is viewed as a difference of 2% or more and thus categorized as a "significant price difference." However, this step alone does not mean the transaction is immediately determined to be dumping.


This standard is designed to prevent situations where some transactions are made at low prices but are masked by a higher overall average, resulting in a finding of no dumping. For example, even if goods are sold at "dumped" prices to only one customer, high prices in other transactions could increase the average sales price of the goods overall. The Department considers that if sales with a price difference of 2% or more account for at least 33% of total U.S. sales, there exists a price difference "pattern." It then examines whether this difference can be reflected through the usual average-to-average price comparison, and if the requirements are met, it calculates the dumping margin using the average-to-transaction (A-to-T) method, which compares the average normal value to each individual U.S. transaction price.


Previously, if price-differentiated transactions represented between 33% and less than 66% of total sales, the A-to-T method was applied to only those transactions. In this case, however, the Department abolished this "mixed method," deciding that if the ratio is at least 33% and requirements are met, the A-to-T method will be applied to all relevant transactions. The CIT recognized this change as well.


The CIT determined the 2% standard to be reasonably grounded, given that the U.S. has long operated a "de minimis dumping margin" rule, which treats a dumping margin below 2% as negligible.



Reporter Hanju Jo, The Law Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing