Seokcheol Hong, Professor of Economics at Seoul National University

Seokcheol Hong, Professor of Economics at Seoul National University

View original image

The government has announced a plan to fully waive tuition fees for incoming students at national universities outside the Seoul metropolitan area starting next year and to extend the benefit to all grades by 2030. The intent is to ease the financial burden of education on young people, prevent the outflow of local talent, and address the risk of regional extinction. Furthermore, there is a strategic calculation to raise the status of key regional universities in support of the national agenda to "create 10 universities comparable to Seoul National University." While this is welcome news for the students and parents who stand to benefit, it is difficult to set aside substantial concerns from the broader perspective of national resource allocation and the sustainability of higher education.


First, the marginal effectiveness of this policy must be scrutinized. Since the introduction of the income-linked National Scholarship Program in 2012, Korea has consistently increased support. The current annual national scholarship budget exceeds 5 trillion KRW, and approximately 1 million university students benefit from it each semester. About 60% of students at regional national universities already receive significant tuition support through these scholarships. In fact, students from low- and middle-income families (income deciles 1–8) are effectively receiving "half-price" or "free" education. Introducing a universal "zero tuition" regardless of income level would, therefore, result in a regressive outcome where the additional public expenditure is concentrated on students from wealthier families (income deciles 9–10) who have so far been excluded from existing support.


It is also questionable how much "zero tuition" will mitigate the concentration in the metropolitan area. The annual tuition at regional national universities is only about half that of major private universities in Seoul, and, thanks to the national scholarship, the actual cost felt by students is already very low. However, young people continue to flock to the metropolitan area not because of high tuition, but because high-quality job opportunities and professional networks are concentrated there. Few students are willing to give up lifetime earnings and career opportunities just to save a few million KRW a year in tuition. This is corroborated by the fact that even past initiatives by some national and public universities offering half-price tuition failed to bring in more talent or change the underlying hierarchy through tuition cuts alone.


Policymakers often cite Germany or Northern Europe's free university education as justification. However, these countries have university enrollment rates of only 30–40% and have established a dual-track system in the labor market through robust vocational training. By contrast, Korea’s college enrollment rate approaches 80%. The environment in Europe, where higher education is strictly selective, cannot be simply compared with Korea, where the vast majority of young people attend university. Under such conditions of educational credential inflation, indiscriminately offering free tuition is tantamount to treating higher education like compulsory primary and secondary education, with the only result being a surge in opportunity costs for fiscal spending.


Thanks to the exceptionally high university attendance rate, Korea's level of human capital accumulation is among the highest in the world, yet hourly labor productivity remains below the OECD median. Despite an abundance of degrees, there is a chronic shortage of innovative talent required by industry—this is the paradox of education inflation. Now is not the time to hand out indiscriminate subsidies to all university students. Instead, the billions of KRW that would be spent on tuition waivers should be intensively invested in expanding advanced research infrastructure, improving outdated educational environments, providing substantial career-focused vocational training tied to local strategic industries, and dramatically increasing living support for top talent—steps that would truly enhance university excellence. Such approaches would genuinely attract talent and provide a practical way to deliver on the goal of "creating 10 universities comparable to Seoul National University."


"Zero tuition" and "free" are always slogans that can easily sway public opinion. However, providing unconditional, cash-based subsidies that ignore rational incentives in the market will do little to shape the futures of young people or enhance the competitiveness of regional universities. The government is unlikely to reverse a policy already announced. At the very least, there must be a rigorous ex post evaluation of whether the public funds have genuinely improved the competitiveness of regional universities.



Seokcheol Hong, Professor of Economics at Seoul National University


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing