'Seoul City Loses Namsan Gondola Appeal'—City Says "Ruling Neglects Citizens' Mobility...Considering Supreme Court Appeal"
Lost in Both First and Second Trials... Construction Resumption Uncertain
Seoul City: "A Ruling That Neglects Private Monopoly and Citizens' Mobility Inconvenience"
Focusing All Efforts on Amending the Enforcement Decree for 'Lawful Project Impl
The Seoul Metropolitan Government, which lost in the second trial regarding the Namsan Gondola project lawsuit, has decided to consider filing an appeal with the Supreme Court. Regardless of the court's ruling, the city also plans to focus all efforts on amending the enforcement decree of the Act on Urban Parks and Green Spaces, which would legally enable the project's implementation.
On September 17, the Seoul Metropolitan Government expressed regret over the Seoul High Court's decision to cancel the disposition on changing the urban management plan for the Namsan Gondola. The city stated, "This is a ruling that neglects the entrenched private monopoly system over the past 60 years and the severe inconvenience in mobility for citizens."
The city added, "In order to guarantee citizens' right to mobility, we will carefully consider an appeal to the Supreme Court, and at the same time, we will devote all efforts to amending the enforcement decree of the Act on Urban Parks and Green Spaces, which is key to resuming construction of the gondola."
Earlier that day, the court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, including Korea Cable Car Industrial Co., Ltd., operator of the Namsan cable car, upholding the lower court’s decision to cancel the disposition by the Seoul Metropolitan Government for changing the urban management plan.
This lawsuit was filed in September 2024 after Seoul changed the land use zoning from Urban Nature Park Zone to Urban Planning Facility Park in order to install a middle support pillar (reinforced concrete post) of at least 30 meters in height for gondola operations. Korea Cable Car Industrial Co., Ltd. and others contested this zoning change.
Korea Cable Car Industrial Co., Ltd. has held a monopoly on the Namsan cable car operation since 1962. Currently, the cable car operates with two cabins, each accommodating 48 people. The city’s plan is to build a gondola system with 25 cabins, each seating 10 people, capable of transporting over 2,000 passengers per hour to improve accessibility.
However, the court in the first trial ruled that the city’s decision did not meet the ‘standards for amending or releasing an Urban Nature Park Zone’ required under the enforcement decree of the Act on Urban Parks and Green Spaces, and ordered the cancellation of the disposition. The verdict was upheld on appeal, again favoring the plaintiffs.
This clause stipulates that the Urban Nature Park Zone may only be released in areas where the function of preserving the natural environment has been significantly degraded by green space destruction or where the area has lost its purpose as a space for leisure and relaxation.
Seoul Mayor Oh Se-hoon attended the groundbreaking ceremony for the Namsan Gondola held on the site of the Lee Hoe-young Memorial Hall within Yejang Park in Jung-gu, Seoul, where the lower station will be built, and delivered a greeting. Photo by Jo Yongjun jun21@
View original imageIn response, the city stated, "This is an incomprehensible decision that failed to adequately reflect the procedural validity and legal requirements that Seoul observed in the urban management plan determination process," and reiterated its position that "the disposition to change the urban management plan is a lawful administrative measure meeting the requirements for altering an Urban Nature Park Zone."
In particular, the city emphasized, "Namsan is an area where urban nature park zones and urban planning park facilities are mixed, and as such, integrated and systematic management as a single park is essential. Amending the urban management plan is a necessary administrative measure for the active creation and management of city parks."
The Seoul Metropolitan Government asserts that if the interpretation that changes to the urban management plan are impossible becomes established, it would make the establishment of plans for developing city parks unfeasible and complicate the legal basis for managing facilities located on the boundaries of different zones and facilities, making integrated management extremely difficult.
Furthermore, the city pointed out that interpreting the law as 'an area must lose its green and leisure function before it can be designated as a facility park' is contradictory—essentially meaning 'a park can only be designated as a park after it has lost its function as a park.'
Namsan, with an average of 12 million visitors annually, has long maintained a monopoly system by the cable car operator for over 60 years, resulting in long waiting lines of over an hour on weekends and during peak seasons. Even for those who take the stairs or use the circular shuttle bus, the final 350-meter stretch to the summit is a steep uphill walk, creating significant barriers for those with limited mobility.
The city concluded, "If the gondola project is ultimately scrapped, it is the citizens who will suffer the consequences. Accordingly, we will thoroughly review the possibility of a Supreme Court appeal and proceed accordingly."
On the 5th, when the groundbreaking ceremony for the Namsan Gondola was held, civic groups opposing the installation of the gondola gathered in front of Yejang Park in Jung-gu, Seoul, and held a rally. The Namsan Gondola operates for 804 meters from Yejang Park (lower station), located 200 meters from Myeongdong Station, to the top of Namsan (upper station). Photo by Jo Yongjun jun21@
View original imageIn addition, the Seoul Metropolitan Government called on the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport to swiftly amend the enforcement decree of the Act on Urban Parks and Green Spaces. In June of last year, the Ministry issued a legislative notice for an amendment to the enforcement decree, which includes relaxing the current 12-meter height restriction on rail and disaster prevention facilities within Urban Nature Park Zones, but the follow-up procedures have been delayed.
The city plans to make every effort to establish a legal basis by pursuing the amendment, as the completion of its procedures would allow the project to proceed lawfully regardless of the outcome of the lawsuit.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Sukkyoon Kang, Director of the Seoul Metropolitan Government's Balanced Development Headquarters, stated, "The court’s recent ruling failed to fully reflect the city’s policy decision to guarantee citizens’ right to mobility and serve the public interest. We will thoroughly review an appeal to the Supreme Court to protect citizens’ mobility rights and ensure Namsan is returned to the public, doing our utmost to see the project through to completion."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.