"Renomination Dispute"
Chief Justice Hoidae Cho:
"The Independence of the Judiciary Must Be Upheld in the Face of Any Challenge"

Chief Justice Hoidae Cho: "Judicial Independence Must Be Upheld in the Face of Any Challenge" View original image

Chief Justice Hoidae Cho stated, "The independence of the judiciary must be upheld in the face of any challenge."


During the opening remarks of the 20th Asia-Pacific Chief Justices' Conference held in Yongsan-gu, Seoul on September 17, Chief Justice Cho said, "This is to ensure that the judiciary fulfills its inherent role of defending democracy and the rule of law."


He continued, "In many countries, increasingly complex political and social disputes are being brought before the courts. People have growing expectations of the judiciary." He added, "In such circumstances, courts must resolutely uphold the law and principles." Furthermore, he emphasized, "All judges must have the courage to adjudicate according to the law and principles, without fear, even when faced with adversity. Chief justices bear a special responsibility to ensure that judges can fulfill these obligations."


Chief Justice Cho further remarked, "For the judiciary to perform its function effectively, mutual respect and cooperation between the judiciary, the legislature, and the executive are necessary." He explained, "Such cooperation helps resolve the complex and multifaceted conflicts present in modern society." He added, "However, such cooperation must be carried out while respecting the unique responsibilities of each institution and guaranteeing the independence of the judiciary. Maintaining a balance between judicial independence and cooperation among the three branches of government, and thereby gaining public trust, is a challenging task. I hope that by sharing our experiences and insights, we can explore constructive ways to faithfully fulfill these responsibilities together."



Meanwhile, tensions remain between the judiciary and the presidential office over the nomination of a Supreme Court justice. On August 18, Chief Justice Cho nominated Son Bongki, Chief Judge of the Daegu District Court, from among four candidates recommended by the Supreme Court Justice Nomination Committee as the successor to former Justice Noh Taeak. However, ten days later, the presidential office requested a re-nomination, describing the nomination as a "unilateral written nomination without substantial consultation." The presidential office indicated its preference for a re-nomination from among the remaining three previously recommended candidates. Within the judiciary, there is increasing support for a plan to reconstitute the Justice Nomination Committee and restart the candidate recommendation process from the beginning, citing the Court Organization Act and related regulations.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing