"Treasury Stock Retirement Becomes the Default After the Third Commercial Act Amendment

Transitioning From a Tool for Management Defense to a Means of Returning Value to Shareholders"

'Corporate Share Buybacks and Cancellations' Seminar Poster (provided by C&G Forum)

'Corporate Share Buybacks and Cancellations' Seminar Poster (provided by C&G Forum)

View original image

'C&G Forum,' a group of experts in corporate governance and management rights (chaired by Professor Kim Min-ki of KAIST), held a regular seminar on September 16, under the theme of 'Corporate Treasury Stock Acquisition and Retirement.'


This seminar was organized to examine the changes in treasury stock regulations following the third amendment to the Commercial Act, which took effect in March 2026, and to discuss the direction of desirable shareholder return policies using recent cases of treasury stock purchases. The seminar was attended by Professor Ahn Sung-jin from Ewha Womans University School of Business, who delivered the keynote presentation, Professor Kim Min-ki from the Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering at KAIST, Kim Hee-kyung, managing attorney at DoYoung Law, and Yoo Hyo-sang, President of the Unicorn Business and Economics Research Institute.


Professor Ahn Sung-jin emphasized, "The third amendment to the Commercial Act marks a paradigm shift, with the treasury stock system returning to its original purpose of shareholder returns." He explained, "The decision to repurchase treasury stock is fundamentally intended as a device for shareholder returns, but in practice, Korean companies have more frequently utilized it for management control defense or other purposes rather than shareholder returns." He added, "Whereas treasury stock retirement was previously optional, after the third amendment to the Commercial Act, retirement has become the default. The system is now transitioning from being a tool for management defense to a means of returning value to shareholders."


Professor Ahn went on to compare and analyze the recent large-scale treasury stock retirement by SK hynix, carried out to return value to shareholders, and Samsung Electronics' very different approach of using treasury stock primarily for employee compensation. He commented, "While the amendment to the Commercial Act is steering treasury stock repurchase to become a vehicle for its original purpose – returning value to shareholders – we must consider whether that goal can be fully achieved under the realities of the Korean capital market and current regulations." He highlighted, "Especially now that selling treasury stock to friendly parties as a means of management defense has been fundamentally blocked, we also need to consider whether alternative defense mechanisms have been properly institutionalized."


During the ensuing panel discussion, participants delved into the changes in the domestic capital market since the implementation of the amended Commercial Act and the challenges that lie ahead. Yoo Hyo-sang explained, "In the United States, companies secure funds for employee compensation through new paid-in capital increases authorized by the shareholders' meeting and then transparently disclose these transactions by quarter. By contrast, Korean companies tend to use treasury stock purchase disclosures as a means of influencing stock prices, which raises concerns about potential market manipulation." On the recent trend of repurchasing treasury stock for employee compensation, he noted, "Unlike in the U.S., where it serves to selectively retain top talent, the practice in Korea of distributing it uniformly to all employees makes it difficult to win shareholder approval and does not align with the original intention of the treasury stock system, which is to enhance shareholder value."


Attorney Kim Hee-kyung stated, "While the fundamental principle of the third amendment to the Commercial Act is treasury stock retirement, some companies are resorting to loopholes – using 'employee compensation' as an excuse to effectively avoid retirement." She added, "Bulk treasury stock purchases concentrated right before the market closes are abnormally increasing market volatility, and using distributable profits for employee compensation rather than for the benefit of shareholders cannot be seen as a true return to shareholders."


Professor Kim Min-ki commented, "The core issue is not whether to retire more treasury stocks, but what principles the board of directors applies when allocating capital. Making the retirement of treasury stocks mandatory is only the starting point in limiting the use of treasury stocks for management control, and the next step is for companies to demonstrate to the market what criteria guide their choices among growth investment, M&A, investment in human capital, dividends, and treasury stock retirement." He went on to say, "Currently, there is inadequate communication to shareholders regarding capital allocation decisions, and insufficient explanation as to why employee compensation should take precedence over treasury stock retirement." He added, "Good corporate governance is not about distributing the most cash, but about allocating capital to where the greatest value can be created, justifying each investment decision, and establishing capital allocation principles that shareholders can trust."


Ultimately, it is expected that how companies establish market trust through strengthened fundamentals and transparent communication with shareholders under the new regulatory environment will be key to advancing the domestic capital market going forward.



Participants at the seminar expressed strong consensus that the treasury stock system should serve its primary purpose of enhancing shareholder value. They agreed on the need for continued discussions on what kind of return policies—between dividends and treasury stock retirement—are most suitable for Korean investors, as well as encouraging companies to voluntarily expand 'retirement-type treasury stock' programs.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing