Portrait Rights Violated Since the Mid-1990s

Lawsuit Launched After Certified Notice Sent in 2019

Actor Paik Ilseob has won a damages lawsuit against a kitchenware company in Busan that used his photos without permission for over 30 years.

Actor Baek Ilseob. Courtesy of KBS.

Actor Baek Ilseob. Courtesy of KBS.

View original image

On September 16, Judge Moon Hyunjung of the 5th Civil Division at the Busan District Court's Western Branch ruled in favor of Paik Ilseob in his damages suit against kitchenware manufacturer and distributor Company A, ordering the defendant to pay the plaintiff 100 million won.


Previously, starting in the mid-1990s, Company A in Busan had affixed stickers bearing Paik Ilseob's image on cookware products such as pots that it manufactured and sold.


His photo was also displayed in product images and descriptions posted on the company's website and online shopping malls. It was reported that some of these products were distributed on certain online platforms under names reminiscent of Paik Ilseob.


In September 2019, Paik Ilseob's representative sent Company A a certified letter, demanding that they cease using his photo without permission and announcing plans for both civil and criminal action.


However, until the company closed this past February, Company A continued using Paik Ilseob’s image in its business as if he were an advertising model for the company. Even after this lawsuit commenced, they did not remove the product images featuring his picture from their website or online shopping malls.


Paik Ilseob's side claimed that Company A's unauthorized use of his images violated his portrait, name, and publicity rights, seeking a total of 154.43 million won in damages—124.43 million won for property damage and 30 million won in consolation money.


The court did not recognize the "right of publicity" asserted by Paik Ilseob’s side as an independent property right, but determined that Company A had committed an illegal act by infringing on his portrait rights.


The court explained, "There is no evidence that an advertising model contract was signed between the plaintiff and defendant, or that the defendant paid advertising fees to the plaintiff. Considering that the plaintiff formally protested the unauthorized use of his likeness in 2019, it is also hard to see this as the plaintiff having implicitly approved the use of his photos without compensation."


The court assessed property damages at 80 million won—and awarded 20 million won for emotional distress—taking into account the compensation Paik Ilseob could have received if a proper contract for the use of his likeness had been in place.



The court concluded, "Every person has the right not to have their facial features or other physical characteristics that allow identification disclosed without consent or exploited for commercial gain. The defendant's use of the plaintiff's photograph in product marketing without his consent constitutes an infringement of portrait rights."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing