The Supreme Court has finalized a not-guilty verdict for a member of a fraud organization who handed his mobile phone to an accomplice just before his arrest to have them hide it, clearing him of the charge of instructing evidence concealment. The ruling was based on the legal principle that, if a person who is asked to hide evidence is also at risk of being prosecuted, then the concealment constitutes hiding their own evidence and is thus not a crime. Therefore, the person who made the request cannot be punished for instructing the concealment.


The Supreme Court’s Criminal Division 2 (Presiding Justice Oh Kyungmi) on August 12, 2026, upheld the lower court's ruling, sentencing Mr. A, who was indicted on charges of fraud and instructing the concealment of evidence, to one year in prison for fraud, while acquitting him of the charge of instructing evidence concealment (Case No. 2026Do8541). Defense attorney Hyunji Kim (6th Bar Exam) represented Mr. A in this case.


[Facts]

Mr. A worked as an account recruiter and handler for a side job part-time fraud ring, transferring 7.5 million won sent by the victim in March 2025 to another account. In July of the same year, as Mr. A anticipated being arrested while returning from Laos, he handed his mobile phone to Mr. B, seated next to him, and instructed him, in substance, to “take care of it and deliver it to my mother.” Mr. B deleted his own conversations with Mr. A and then passed the mobile phone to Mr. A’s family.


Mr. B was indicted for evidence concealment and violating the Electronic Financial Transactions Act, and received a sentence of six months in prison with one year of probation.


[Lower Court Rulings]

The first trial found Mr. A guilty on all charges and sentenced him to one year in prison. On appeal, the court acknowledged the possibility that Mr. A’s actions constituted the concealment of his own evidence and found it difficult to conclude that serious obstruction to the investigation had occurred. As a result, it ruled Mr. A not guilty of instructing evidence concealment but sentenced him to one year in prison for fraud.


[Supreme Court Judgment (Summary)]

- Mr. B independently decided to keep, deliver, and delete conversations from the mobile phone. He cannot be regarded as a mere instrument lacking criminal intent for evidence concealment, nor can Mr. A’s actions be construed as using an unpunishable person as a tool for evidence concealment.


- Since Mr. B was subject to criminal punishment for lending access media, and the mobile phone likely contained evidence relating to his own lending activities and payment records, it is difficult to exclude the possibility that Mr. B hid evidence to avoid his own prosecution.


- As hiding evidence in one’s own criminal case does not constitute the crime of evidence concealment, Mr. A likewise cannot be found guilty of instructing evidence concealment. While some findings of the lower court were inappropriate, the conclusion that Mr. A cannot be punished for instructing evidence concealment is valid.



Reporter Sangwoo Lee, The Law Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing