Posting of Outdated 27-Year-Old Guideline Despite Rule Changes

"Insufficient Understanding of the Right to Counsel"

Recently, controversy has arisen over notices posted at police stations that could be interpreted as belittling lawyers or disregarding the right to assistance of counsel. At one police station, a sign compared lawyers to "expensive substitute drivers," while another displayed a 27-year-old directive stating that a defense attorney's participation could be limited for suspects in organized crime or drug cases. The police explained that, in reality, there have been no cases in which the right to counsel has been violated.


"The most expensive substitute driver in the world is a lawyer."


This is the message posted on the glass wall leading to the detention center interview room at Uijeongbu Police Station on September 13, 2026. The message suggests that, instead of spending a significant amount on hiring a lawyer after being arrested for drunk driving, individuals should use a substitute driver from the start.


Lawyers who saw this notice criticized it for portraying the role of attorneys—who protect the constitutionally guaranteed rights of suspects to defend themselves—as merely "costly cleanup," thereby trivializing their essential function.


Uijeongbu Police Station acknowledged that the intention was to raise awareness about the seriousness of drunk driving but admitted an inappropriate choice of wording. The notice was removed after the Seoul Bar Association raised the issue.


Four days earlier, on September 9, at Sangju Police Station in North Gyeongsang Province, it was discovered that a notice was posted stating that the participation of defense attorneys could be restricted during investigations of certain cases, such as organized crime or drug offenses.


Under current law, attorney participation cannot be restricted solely based on the type of crime. However, the National Police Agency continued to display the "Guidelines for Participation of Defense Counsel During Suspect Interrogations" enacted in 1999. Since the insertion of Article 243-2 into the Criminal Procedure Act in 2007, it has been expressly stipulated in law that, unless there is a just cause, defense attorneys must be allowed to participate during suspect interrogations. Police investigation regulations also allow restrictions only if significant hindrance to the investigation is likely from the attorney's participation. Article 12, Clause 4 of the Constitution also guarantees the right to assistance of counsel for those who are arrested or detained.


A Sangju Police Station official explained, "Due to an oversight, we failed to notice the outdated notice that had been posted."


With similar controversies arising just days apart, calls are growing to assess investigative officers’ awareness of the right to counsel at field investigation sites. Lawyers report instances where suspects who express a wish to be investigated with their attorneys present are told by some investigators that "there is no need to bring a lawyer" or "it's not serious enough for that." There are reportedly clients who, after hearing such comments, worry that hiring a lawyer might disadvantage them.


As the controversy intensified, Cho Sunyeol, President of the Seoul Bar Association (Judicial Research and Training Institute, 33rd class), visited the National Office of Investigation and Uijeongbu Police Station to demand measures to prevent recurrence. President Cho stated, "If such incidents keep occurring at investigative agencies, the right to the assistance of counsel could be rendered meaningless, so outdated mindsets must change."



Reporter Seo Hayeon, Legal Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing