The "Clarity Act," a bill aimed at setting legal standards for the virtual asset market, failed to pass a procedural vote in the U.S. Senate. The bill's progress came to a halt as Democratic opposition, citing insufficient ethical regulations related to U.S. President Donald Trump's virtual asset businesses, was joined by several Republican senators. As a result, the prices of major virtual assets, including Bitcoin, have been under pressure.


Associated Press Yonhap News

Associated Press Yonhap News

View original image

According to Bloomberg and the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) on September 15 (local time), the bill, known as the "Clarity Act," fell short of the 60 votes required to advance to Senate debate. The final tally was 49 in favor and 50 against. All Democratic senators voted against the motion, and four Republicans also dissented, causing the bill to fall short of the threshold to begin formal debate, which required 60 votes.


The legislation, which had been the subject of negotiations for over a year and was expected to establish the first comprehensive regulatory framework for the virtual asset market, failed to reach a bipartisan compromise before the vote. Notably, Democrats and Republicans were sharply divided over whether to restrict President Trump's ability to profit from the virtual asset industry through the bill.


Senator Mark Warner, a Democrat from Virginia, stated that he voted against the bill because it failed to address what he called a "fundamental conflict of interest" involving President Trump's virtual asset businesses. In a statement, Warner said, "A president must not use the powers and influence of the office to benefit their own virtual asset holdings while their administration makes decisions that could directly impact those holdings." He further stated, "At the very least, any serious virtual asset legislation should include substantive ethical requirements to prevent the president and other senior government officials from profiting from policies they oversee."


There was also a clash between the virtual asset industry and the banking sector. The two sides were deeply divided over whether platforms such as Coinbase should be allowed to provide users with reward payments similar to bank interest. Banking associations argued that such recurring reward payments could drain deposits from regional banks, undermining their lending capacity. Senator Josh Hawley, a Republican from Missouri, said he voted against the bill due to concerns that his constituents might find it harder to secure loans. "Many farmers in our state are especially concerned that, as written, the bill could prevent them from getting loans," he said.


This failed procedural vote does not mean the bill is dead. Since the vote was to enter full Senate consideration—not to make a final decision—the Republican leadership could push for another vote by persuading Democrats and dissenting members of its own party. However, with the U.S. Congress set to enter recess ahead of the November midterm elections, there is little time left for renegotiation and another vote.


The outcome of the midterm elections is another variable. The WSJ noted that if the Republican Party loses its majority, the House of Representatives may need to reconsider the bill during a lame-duck session even if the Senate passes a revised version. In such a scenario, with limited time to reconcile differences between the chambers, there is an increased risk that passage of the bill will remain stalled.



Meanwhile, the failure of the vote led to a drop in prices of major virtual assets. According to CoinMarketCap, as of 9:47 a.m. on September 16, Bitcoin was trading at $75,709.01, down 2.88% from 24 hours earlier. Leading altcoins—including Ethereum, Ripple (XRP), and Solana—also declined by 4% to 9%.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing