Before assessing roles and workload,
the focus shifts to changing the name of judicial oversight
Downsizing should not be seen as the achievement of reform

[Reporter’s Notebook] Criminal Justice Reform Trapped in the Pursuit of "Erasing Traces of the Prosecution" View original image

"The term 'judicial oversight' is not a concept that just appeared out of thin air."


A senior prosecutor I recently spoke to commented on the ongoing controversy surrounding the "Judicial Oversight Division" in the proposed Public Prosecution Office organizational structure. He explained that investigations, by their very nature, restrict the fundamental rights of citizens, and "judicial oversight" has long been a legal concept used to verify whether investigative procedures and processes are conducted in accordance with laws and due procedure.


On September 13, the ruling party, the government, and the presidential office decided to consider changing the division’s name from "Judicial Oversight Division" to "Non-Indictment Case Review Division." They reasoned that the label "judicial oversight" could lead to misunderstandings, suggesting prosecutors would be controlling the police. Following instructions from President Lee Jaemyung, even a plan to readjust the number of prosecutors is now being discussed.


If a name leads to misunderstanding, it can be changed. The argument to only employ the necessary workforce is also not without merit. The real issue, however, is that, before discussing the division’s function or workload, policymakers seem to be competing to see how much of a "trace of the prosecution" they can erase. Judicial oversight refers to reviewing warrants requested by police, demanding corrective action for illegal investigations, and re-examining non-indictment cases. There have even been instances where a police investigation involved calling a suspect who intended to turn themselves in outside, staging a scene to make it look coincidental, and then making an emergency arrest—only for judicial oversight to later correct such misconduct.


The elimination of the prosecution office would not mean these responsibilities disappear. Even if direct investigations and supplementary investigations are abolished, tasks such as reviewing warrants, assessing non-indictment cases, maintaining indictments, and recovering criminal proceeds will remain. The new system has also introduced a procedure in which police can request prosecutors’ legal opinions when needed. Yet, even before launching the Public Prosecution Office, there is talk of drastically reducing personnel and listing the number of prosecutors as a target for cuts. The order of priorities appears to be reversed.


It is even more ironic that, on the same day, the ruling party insisted that "police reform must be pursued even more vigorously than prosecution reform." At the same time, in response to the poor handling of the missing persons case of Jang Miran in Jeju, authorities decided to increase dedicated police staff and create a new related organization. In effect, different standards are being applied to prosecution and police, all in the name of reform.



The essence of prosecution reform is to eliminate excessive authority. However, this should not make it more difficult for the newly established Public Prosecution Office to perform its necessary functions. Can downsizing be considered the true achievement of reform? One must question whether reform is merely about erasing every trace of the prosecution.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing