If a private school teacher requests to appear at a disciplinary committee together with their attorney to provide testimony and the committee denies this request while proceeding with the disciplinary process, any disciplinary action taken is procedurally invalid due to a significant procedural flaw, according to a Supreme Court ruling. This is the first Supreme Court judgment to explicitly confirm the legal principle that the presence of an attorney and an opportunity to make statements must be guaranteed during disciplinary proceedings for private school teachers.


The Third Criminal Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Lee Heung-gu), on August 13, 2026, overturned a previous ruling that had rejected Assistant Professor A’s lawsuit to cancel the decision of the Teacher Appeal Review Committee (case number 2024Du61155) and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court. The lawsuit was represented by attorneys Song Hae-eun (Judicial Research and Training Institute, 15th class) and Kim Kuk-yeol (35th class) of Dongin Law Group, and Cho Jeong-hee (31st class) and Kim Ju-hyun (39th class) of Decode Law Group.


[Facts]

In 2022, A was dismissed from the university after being reviewed by the Disciplinary Committee for faculty due to on-campus misconduct, including sexual harassment and assault. A requested to appear before the committee together with their appointed attorney to provide testimony, but this request was denied. The committee informed A that the attorney could wait in a nearby waiting room and, if necessary, consult with the teacher and testify afterward. However, during the actual review, no consultation or advice occurred between A and the waiting attorney.


[Lower Court Rulings]

Both the first and second instance courts (the latter being the appellate court) ruled against the plaintiff. They held that there was insufficient legal basis for the right to have an attorney present during the proceedings, and noted that since the attorney was allowed to wait nearby and could potentially consult, there was no substantial infringement of the right to defense.


[Supreme Court Ruling (Summary)]

- In disciplinary procedures imposing disadvantages, such as disciplinary action against public officials including teachers at national or public schools, it is necessary to guarantee the right to defense through representation by an attorney. The level of procedural protection for private school teachers in disciplinary proceedings should be ensured to match that afforded to teachers at national and public schools.


- The participation of a private school teacher’s appointed attorney together with the teacher at the committee, and the attorney’s opportunity to provide necessary statements, constitutes an essential element of the right to defense. Unless there are exceptional circumstances, such participation cannot be denied. If disciplinary proceedings are carried out without substantively guaranteeing this right, there is a major procedural flaw that, in principle, renders the disciplinary action void.



Reporter Mina Han, The Law Times


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing