Korea-America Association Holds Foreign Affairs and Security Seminar on September 14

Victor Cha of CSIS: "South Korea Must Prepare for the Resumption of U.S.-North Korea Talks"

As the U.S. National Defense Strategy (NDS) for 2026 outlines a direction in which South Korea would take on the primary responsibility for deterring North Korea, recommendations have emerged that South Korea should leverage its own capabilities to lead the modernization of the South Korea-U.S. alliance. Concerns have also surfaced regarding the potential reduction of the U.S. role and the growing uncertainty of U.S. policy toward North Korea.


On the 14th, a seminar titled "The Impact of Changes in U.S. Security Strategy on the Korean Peninsula" was held at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Jung-gu, Seoul, hosted by the Korea-America Association. Victor Cha, Korea Chair at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), delivered the keynote address via video. Courtesy of the Korea-America Association

On the 14th, a seminar titled "The Impact of Changes in U.S. Security Strategy on the Korean Peninsula" was held at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Jung-gu, Seoul, hosted by the Korea-America Association. Victor Cha, Korea Chair at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), delivered the keynote address via video. Courtesy of the Korea-America Association

View original image

On September 14, Victor Cha, Korea Chair at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), stated in his keynote address at the seminar titled "The Impact of Changes in U.S. Security Strategy on the Korean Peninsula"—hosted by the Korea-America Association at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Seoul—that "it should not be seen as the U.S. abandoning the defense of South Korea," and emphasized, "While the U.S. commitment remains firm, there are expectations that South Korea will assume a greater share of the burden for defense and deterrence."


The 2026 NDS, released by the U.S. Department of Defense earlier this year, clearly states that South Korea—based on strong military capabilities, high defense spending, a robust defense industry, and a conscription system—is capable of taking primary responsibility for deterring North Korea, under U.S. support that is central but more limited. Cha explained, "There is less new here than people might think," noting that the U.S. has, for decades, asked South Korea to play a greater role in its own defense.


However, he stressed that issues such as the role of U.S. Forces Korea and the transfer of wartime operational control should be addressed not individually but within the broader framework of alliance modernization. Cha stated, "What is more important than the actual troop numbers is the extent to which combined capabilities, cooperation, and alignment are maintained stably," and added, "Changes in U.S. military posture should not be individual or unilateral actions, but rather implemented as part of a broader vision for alliance modernization." He cautioned, "Otherwise, South Korea may feel severe abandonment, and North Korea may see this as a potential opportunity."


On the recent reduction of joint South Korea-U.S. military exercises, Cha evaluated that this could negatively impact military readiness, assurance for allies, and deterrence against North Korea as a whole. He assessed that U.S. President Donald Trump's reduction of joint exercises was "the first concrete action" taken to bring North Korean leader Kim Jong Un to the negotiating table, but also added, "I don't think there is any way to sugarcoat the natural consequences that will appear if training is reduced for an extended period."


During the following Q&A, Cha emphasized that South Korea should also be diplomatically prepared for the possibility of a resumption of North Korea-U.S. summit diplomacy. He remarked, "What’s important for South Korea is to be prepared diplomatically," and suggested that if President Trump and Kim meet again, "it would be ideal for the South Korean president to act as the Japanese prime minister did." Citing the example of the late Shinzo Abe, former Japanese Prime Minister, who maintained continuous contact with President Trump during the first round of North Korea-U.S. summit diplomacy, he added, "If the South Korean president can talk freely with the U.S. president and discuss what South Korea's role should be in these dialogues, it would lead to a better direction."


Seo Junggeon, professor of Political Science and International Relations at Kyung Hee University, recommended that South Korea should not simply respond to alliance modernization as presented by the U.S., but should define the direction of alliance modernization on its own terms. Professor Seo stated, "It is extremely important that we do not just have a reactive attitude to the U.S. version of alliance modernization, but seriously consider what modernization of the South Korea-U.S. alliance means to us."


In military and security fields, Professor Seo saw the need for South Korea to accept the reality of being asked for greater responsibility and capability in deterring North Korea, but also highlighted the importance of securing the U.S. commitment to strategic assets and extended deterrence. In the area of economic security, he emphasized that South Korea’s strengths in shipbuilding, semiconductors, and supply chains should be utilized to advance the alliance. In response to U.S. political polarization, he added that South Korea should expand its points of contact with U.S. states, governors, and state legislatures, so as not to become exclusively reliant on any single administration or party.


Choi Byeonghyuk, former Ambassador to Saudi Arabia and former Deputy Commander of the ROK-U.S. Combined Forces Command, diagnosed the changes in U.S. strategy as both a crisis and an opportunity for South Korea. The former Deputy Commander remarked, "Previously, South Korea was in a one-sided, dependency-based alliance, but now it is vital to instill in the U.S. the perception that South Korea is a necessary partner, sharing the advanced technology and production capabilities that the U.S. needs for the future."


He particularly emphasized that South Korea’s defense production capacity could serve as a leverage point for collaboration. The former ambassador stated, "South Korea possesses several essential capabilities that the U.S. requires, such as shipbuilding and munitions manufacturing; in the current situation where U.S. stockpiles are dwindling, South Korea has the mass production capacity to replenish them," and added, "South Korea’s involvement in defense industry cooperation with the U.S. could actually serve as a favorable opportunity for South Korea."


He also suggested linking the expanded responsibility of the South Korean military for defense against North Korea with South Korea's own requests. He explained, "While the South Korean military assumes primary responsibility for conventional defense against North Korea, we could negotiate other issues we are pursuing—such as the construction of nuclear-powered submarines or revisions to the nuclear cooperation agreement—to be raised to a level similar to that of Japan."


On the other hand, some voices cautioned that alliance modernization might increase South Korea's responsibilities while reducing the predictability of the security guarantees provided by the U.S. Hwang Taehee, professor of Political Science and International Relations at Yonsei University, stated, "Alliance modernization effectively means South Korea's responsibilities sharply increase, but the level of predictable protection sharply decreases, and thus uncertainty rises significantly."



Lee Geunwook, professor of Political Science and International Relations at Sogang University, also emphasized that if the U.S. is to push for alliance modernization, it must also consider the capabilities and sustainability needed to support this in practice. He pointed out that the U.S. consumption of military resources while responding to multiple regional conflicts could also affect South Korea and East Asia.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing