[Insight & Opinion] 'In the Name of Reform' and Reform
Judicial and Prosecution Reform Disputes Ignore People's Livelihoods
Negotiating Conflicting Interests Is 'Harder Than a Revolution'
Hardliners' Abuse of Power Leads to Declining Approval Ratings
"The biggest obstacle to reform is obstructing reform in the name of reform."
On September 12, President Lee Jae-myung wrote this on his social media account. Through this message, he aimed to directly refute criticism from some within the ruling party, who have argued that the president lacks determination for reform. Critics argue that insufficient reform is causing a rift in the core base of support, which, in turn, leads to a decline in approval ratings. However, President Lee saw these criticisms as "radical agitation that exploits the genuine aspirations of some for revolutionary change in order to highlight one’s own purity." He added that this agitation "inevitably hinders reform and causes backlash by provoking resistance and counter-coalescence," thus taking a strong stance against such attacks.
There is some validity to the president's approach to reform. However, it is questionable whether the prosecution reform emphasized by hardliners is truly the path toward the democratic and equitable society that President Lee envisions. It appears to be more of a political power struggle adopted by a different faction. Likewise, the president's reform strategy aimed at a more democratic and harmonious society remains unclear. Rather than a matter of disagreement over methodology, it is a situation where hardline opinions cloaked in the "name of reform" and the ambiguous agenda of reform advocates are talking past each other, resulting in unresolved debate.
True reform aims to radically change and improve longstanding problems. While most agree on the need for improvement, implementation is difficult. Entrenched vested interests, who have also benefited from accumulated evils, strongly resist such changes, making it hard to coordinate competing interests. While a revolution—executed by overriding existing laws and sometimes employing violence—could address problems in a single stroke, reform requires coordination of interests within the existing legal order, and must weigh the advantages and disadvantages of its effects. This is why reform, regardless of how successful its final outcome may be, is often considered more difficult than a revolution.
Most administrations throughout history have declared reform as their agenda. The government that most credibly pursued reform was the Kim Young-sam administration, which championed civil reform. It carried out bold and sweeping reforms, such as implementing the real-name financial system, dismantling the military faction Hanahoe, and demolishing the former Japanese Governor-General’s building, all of which won widespread public support. While subsequent administrations, such as Park Geun-hye’s with her "Normalization of the Abnormal," have also put forward various reform agendas, these attempts often proved ineffective or became self-contradictory due to the ruler's own anti-reform exercises of power.
Prosecution reform under the Lee Jae-myung administration is a continuation of the state agency reforms pursued under the Moon Jae-in administration. However, this reform has become distorted into a political strategy for power struggles under the guise of reform. Under Moon, prosecution reform received particular attention, and the administration claimed to have achieved institutional changes by implementing legislation that adjusted investigative authority between the police and the prosecution and by establishing the Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials. However, what was once said to be a matter of improving practices returned as a political weapon during the so-called "Cho Kuk incident."
President Lee Jae-myung is seated after the national anthem at the Chief Presidential Secretary meeting held at the Blue House on the 11th.
[Photo by Cheongwadae Press Photographers Group] Yonhap News
Alongside President Lee's ongoing judicial risks, prosecution reform—distorted by its transformation into a power struggle—was joined by judicial reform efforts as well. The abolition of the prosecution office and the elimination of the supplementary investigation authority, known as 'complete deprivation of prosecution investigative authority,' were accomplished, along with the institutionalization of the so-called "Three Laws on Judicial Reform." However, the institutional flaws of these measures taken under the name of reform, as well as constitutional controversies over some of them, have been pointed out. Despite these concerns, the administration pushed through with these hardline measures in the name of reform. Ultimately, hardliners have wrapped their own demands to become the mainstream force in the Lee Jae-myung administration under the rhetoric of reform.
In summary, the decline in the president's approval rating should be attributed not to a lack of willingness for reform, but, on the contrary, to the abuse of power masked as reform. National administrative resources have been consumed by power struggles that serve only the interests of those in power, which are irrelevant to the daily lives of citizens. Wrapping factional power struggles with political motives in the rhetoric of reform is worse than ineffective reform. The root of the problem lies with the political powers themselves, who claim to be the agents of reform.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim Manheum, former Chief of the National Assembly Legislative Research Office
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.