Investigation of Modular Classroom Contracts Over the Past Four Years
Relatives' Companies Mobilized; Prices Inflated Threefold
"Exploiting Loopholes in the 'Catalog Contract System'"

A corrupt company involved in bid-rigging worth 130 billion won in the supply of modular classrooms as temporary classrooms to elementary, middle, and high schools nationwide has been uncovered.

On the morning of the 2nd, examinees are preparing for exams at Gwangnam High School in Gwangjin-gu, Seoul. Photo by Joint Press Corps

On the morning of the 2nd, examinees are preparing for exams at Gwangnam High School in Gwangjin-gu, Seoul. Photo by Joint Press Corps

View original image

The Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission announced on the 14th that it investigated the status of modular classroom catalog contracts at 33 elementary, middle, and high schools in 13 regions across the country over the past four years, and found indications that a certain company, in collusion with its affiliated entities, engaged in large-scale bid-rigging totaling about 130 billion won. These companies exploited institutional loopholes in the catalog contract system to inflate product prices by more than three times.


The investigation found that Companies B and C, which are closely connected to Company A, were spin-offs from Company A in 2020 and were typical related parties, with spouses and relatives serving as executives and representatives. The owner of Company A also served as a co-CEO at Company B along with relatives, and the representative of Company C was the spouse of Company A's CEO.


From August 2022 to July this year, Company A and its affiliates leveraged these relationships to exclusively win 99 out of 324 total modular classroom catalog contract awards (accounting for about 31%), worth 130 billion won, over a four-year period. Company A signed 76 contracts (worth 100 billion won), while Company B signed 23 contracts (worth 29.3 billion won). Company C did not actually win any contracts but participated as a decoy bidder.


This bid-rigging exploited a structural weakness in the catalog contract method, under which service contracts are signed based on price quotations requested by the purchasing institution. However, there is no standard for calculating prices, so, in practice, schools relied on cost estimates provided by the catalog-registered companies. As a result, the prices proposed by buyers were set high, which led to excessively high final contract prices. The unit price for modular classrooms under a catalog contract reached up to 67.2 million won per module—more than three times higher than the price under the standard lump-sum bidding method (maximum 22.2 million won).


The bidding-rigging tactics of Company A and affiliates were meticulous. In some cases, school principals took the lead by basing proposal prices only on estimates from the colluding companies and arranged for other companies to participate as decoys. Alternatively, Company A would visit schools directly to pre-arrange winning bids or involve decoy bidders who would purposely fail to submit required documentation to facilitate Company A's win. In certain educational institutions, evaluation criteria were adopted that overwhelmingly advantaged Company A.


Illegal activities were also discovered regarding quality control and delivery. Company A violated the contractual obligation to manufacture products directly by having Company B's factory produce and deliver the products instead, then sharing the profits. While contract terms required at least two indoor air quality measurements prior to use, in most cases, the educational institutions delegated the measurement to suppliers and only received the reports, making it difficult to verify the reliability of inspection results.


Based on its findings, the Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission referred the case to relevant agencies and demanded strict action. It requested that the Fair Trade Commission investigate the bid-rigging acts by specific companies and asked the National Police Agency to look into violations of the direct manufacturing standard, obstruction of official duties by employees of educational institutions, and bid-rigging. The Public Procurement Service and metropolitan/provincial education offices were recommended to introduce step-by-step system improvements in the contracting process to prevent future corruption.



Lee Myungsun, Vice Chairperson for Anti-Corruption at the commission, stated, "Bid-rigging by certain companies is a serious criminal act that obstructs fair competition and undermines trust in the market. Since modular classrooms are directly linked to the safety and health of students and teachers, strict measures will be taken, and we will continue to monitor and eradicate such unfair contracting practices in the future."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing