A Challenge to the Traditional Powerhouse, Baskin-Robbins
Competition Heats Up in the Store-Based Premium Ice Cream Market

# In the mid-2000s, the main battleground for store-based premium ice cream was Seoul's famed Sinchon Street, known as the "Street of Youth." In this area, the brightly pink "Baskin-Robbins" and the dark green signage of "Natuur" faced off in large, single-brand stores occupying the second and third floors. University students and young people in their twenties and thirties packed these stores, which featured expansive glass windows. To capture the tastes and preferences of Sinchon, a key commercial district, the two brands waged an intense daily battle.


# Some twenty years later, in 2026, store-based premium ice cream companies have begun a new battle near Gangnam Station in Seoul. While the traditionally dominant pink "Baskin-Robbins" holds key locations, the blue-hued "Benson" and the creamy pale "Van Leeuwen" have issued a challenge. Both newcomers highlight the use of minimal additives and a focus on basic ingredients to emphasize authentic flavors. When Baskin-Robbins first opened its doors in 1986, its catchphrase was: "Experience the country's first all-natural ice cream, Thirty-One."

Newsletter content at the time of Baskin-Robbins' first store opening. Screenshot from the Baskin-Robbins website

Newsletter content at the time of Baskin-Robbins' first store opening. Screenshot from the Baskin-Robbins website

View original image

A generational shift is underway in the store-based premium ice cream market. Natuur, which once fiercely competed with Baskin-Robbins, has exited the store business. Meanwhile, the emerging players Benson and Van Leeuwen are rapidly expanding their presence by opening new stores at key locations, including Gangnam Station. These brands are meticulously preparing to entice consumers not only during the peak summer season, but also in the off-peak autumn and winter months.


According to the industry as of September 13, Lotte Wellfood voluntarily cancelled the franchise business information disclosure for Natuur, which had been registered with the Korea Fair Trade Commission, on August 4. This follows the closure of all directly managed Natuur stores by the end of last year and the winding down of operations at the approximately eight remaining franchise outlets nationwide by late June of this year.


Natuur, which launched its brand in 1998 with a differentiated focus on premium and vegan ice cream, once operated more than 200 stores at its peak, centering around its bestselling green tea ice cream. However, in 2026, 29 years after its launch, the brand has completely withdrawn from the store business. An official from Lotte Wellfood stated, "The store business has now come to a complete end," adding, "Because Lotte Wellfood’s strength lies more in food manufacturing and distribution rather than operating stores, we plan to focus on supplying finished products through retail channels going forward."


The premium ice cream market in Korea has a history spanning over 40 years. The norm is to avoid additives and use only the finest ingredients and fresh milk. Unlike mass-produced ice cream, the latest trend is to increase milk fat while reducing air incorporation, resulting in a chewy texture and enhanced flavor of the raw ingredients themselves.


Natuur Leaves, Benson and Van Leeuwen Arrive... Will They Shake Baskin-Robbins’ Dominance? View original image

The undisputed powerhouse in Korea's premium ice cream market is Baskin-Robbins, operated by BR Korea, an affiliate of Sammitang Holdings. Starting with its flagship Myeongdong store in 1986, Baskin-Robbins rapidly expanded to major locations and, as of 2024, operates 1,747 stores nationwide. The pace of store expansion, which continued to increase through 2023 (1,752 stores), has recently slowed. BR Korea, the operator behind Baskin-Robbins, has recorded operating losses for three consecutive years.


In the meantime, Benson and Van Leeuwen have entered the market as new players. Benson, a brand launched in May of last year by Verus Coop Creamery, a subsidiary of Hanwha Galleria, is focusing on aggressive store expansion. It currently has 23 locations, with plans to reach 30 stores by the end of this year and its 100th store next year. Van Leeuwen, an American brand brought in by Twosome Place as a master franchise, opened its first location in July of this year and currently operates three stores, including the Gangnam Station branch.


Natuur Leaves, Benson and Van Leeuwen Arrive... Will They Shake Baskin-Robbins’ Dominance? View original image
Natuur Leaves, Benson and Van Leeuwen Arrive... Will They Shake Baskin-Robbins’ Dominance? View original image

Baskin-Robbins responds to the challenge with its diverse array of flavors and textures, which have long powered its store expansion. It also continues to lead the trend in the ice cream cake market, where it enjoys a dominant position. The challengers, Benson and Van Leeuwen, aim to compete on the strength of premium ice cream with top-quality ingredients and a commitment to authenticity.


Having made it through the peak summer season, these companies are turning their attention to capturing consumer tastes during the autumn and winter off-season. Although seasonality has less impact than in the past, experts note that unique strategies are still required due to the nature of the business selling cold desserts. These brands also offer coffee, signature beverages, and dessert menus in addition to their ice cream products.


This month, Baskin-Robbins is showcasing new ice cream products and gift macaron sets suited for the Chuseok season, and collaborating with brands such as "Tokyo Banana" and "Monchhichi." Next month, it will release new items inspired by winners of its consumer-participation "Gray Flavor Contest." A Baskin-Robbins representative commented, "We plan to actively meet season-driven demand by introducing an array of new and creative cake concepts for the year-end Christmas season."

Baskin-Robbins collaborated with Japan's leading dessert brand "Tokyo Banana" earlier this month to launch the "Tokyo Banana Crème Brûlée". Provided by Baskin-Robbins

Baskin-Robbins collaborated with Japan's leading dessert brand "Tokyo Banana" earlier this month to launch the "Tokyo Banana Crème Brûlée". Provided by Baskin-Robbins

View original image

Based on its first experience with the fall and winter off-season after its launch last year, Benson is placing particular emphasis on store expansion this year as well as diversification of sales channels, such as delivery and gift-giving via KakaoTalk. The company also plans to enhance the variety and product appeal of its ice cream cakes, and increase its production capacity to meet surging year-end demand. In particular, Benson will introduce options to prevent flavor mixing in packaging and delivery for the winter, and expand promotions for Christmas and the holiday season.


Van Leeuwen, which is still in the early stages of its store openings, plans to focus this year on promoting its brand and selling products through the three stores currently in operation.



An industry official stated, "As high inflation and economic slowdown continue, the trend of enjoying 'small luxuries' is being sustained, which is also fueling growth in the premium ice cream market. Baskin-Robbins, with its more than 1,700 stores nationwide, and the newer entrants Benson and Van Leeuwen, which are now focusing on opening new stores, will each need to pursue different strategies to capture consumers' tastes."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing