The confirmation hearing for Justice Minister nominee Kim Seung-won, scheduled for the 15th, is now likely to proceed without any witnesses or reference persons. The People Power Party demanded the adoption of 44 witnesses and 4 reference persons, but the Democratic Party refused to accept the proposal. According to the National Assembly Personnel Hearing Act, the request for attendance must be delivered at least five days before the hearing date, so the Legislation and Judiciary Committee should have completed the selection of witnesses by the 9th. Similarly, the confirmation hearing for Gender Equality and Family Minister nominee Yong Hye-in also faced discord over scheduling and witness selection, leading to the cancellation of the Gender Equality and Family Committee’s plenary session on the 10th. The National Defense Committee likewise failed to reach an agreement on witness adoption for Defense Minister nominee Kang Shin-chul's confirmation hearing.


At some point, confirmation hearings have come to be seen less as a process of rigorous screening and more as a mere formality for appointments. While the presidential office claims that "the personnel hearing system itself is a process for the public to scrutinize nominees," the phenomenon of "hearings without witnesses" has continued from the first cabinet term into the second. The Asia Business Daily pointed out in June that 19 out of 24 hearings held since the start of the Lee Jae-myung administration took place without witnesses, and less than three months later the same issue has repeated.


Not all demands for witnesses by the opposition are justified. If the requests involve matters for which investigations have already concluded, or individuals of little relevance intended only for political attacks and public humiliation, these should be filtered out. Likewise, not every hearing must have witnesses. However, in cases like this, where positions directly clash and public interest is high, at least a few key individuals relevant to the facts should be summoned. While Legislation and Judiciary Committee chairwoman Seo Young-kyo stated, "It is common to hold hearings without witnesses," it should be noted that in 2019, 11 witnesses were adopted for the hearing of former minister Cho Kuk, and in 2022, four witnesses appeared at the hearing for former minister Han Dong-hoon. Refusing to adopt even a single witness on the grounds of excessive demands is no different from giving up on verification itself.



The Democratic Party should cooperate in adopting at least the minimum number of witnesses and reference persons necessary to verify the key suspicions surrounding the nominees. The National Assembly also needs to revise the current Personnel Hearing Act, under which failure of bipartisan agreement leads to the entire witness process falling through. If a hearing consists solely of listening to explanations without any verification, the public cannot help but question its very purpose.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing