Procedural Fairness Comes Before Disciplinary Action for Sexual Misconduct

Supreme Court: "Disciplinary Action is Invalid if Legal Counsel is Barred"

A Wake-Up Call for Disciplinary Procedures at Private Schools

Supreme Court: "Refusal to Allow Lawyer's Presence Is Not Permissible"

The photo and the article content are not related. Yonhap News Agency

The photo and the article content are not related. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court has ruled that if a disciplinary committee at a private school refuses to allow the presence of a lawyer representing the individual subject to disciplinary action, this constitutes a violation of the right to defense and renders the disciplinary measure invalid.


According to the legal community on September 14, the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Lee Heung-gu) overturned a lower court ruling that had ruled against the plaintiff in the final appeal of a lawsuit filed by Mr. B, a former associate professor at University A, seeking to confirm the invalidation of his dismissal, and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court. Previously, Mr. B was dismissed by the disciplinary committee of University A in 2022 for misconduct, including sexual harassment and forcible molestation against a graduate student under his supervision in 2021.


At the time, Mr. B requested to be accompanied by his appointed lawyer to the disciplinary committee so that he could make statements with legal counsel present. However, the committee denied this request and instead had the lawyer wait in a nearby room, informing Mr. B that he could consult the lawyer and then make statements if necessary. In practice, no consultation with the lawyer took place during the meeting.


The trial judges in the first and second instances found no fault with the university's disciplinary process. The lower courts ruled that "disciplinary action against private school teachers does not constitute a 'disposition' as defined by the Administrative Procedures Act, and therefore, the right to legal representation is not guaranteed by law." They also determined that "since the lawyer was waiting nearby and could provide support, there was no hindrance to effectively exercising the right to defense," and dismissed Mr. B’s claim.



However, the Supreme Court's ruling was different. The court overturned the lower court's decision, stating that even in private schools, the right to legal counsel, which is central to the right to defense in disciplinary proceedings, must be strictly protected. The Supreme Court panel stated, "It is an essential part of exercising the right to defense for a lawyer appointed by a private school teacher to be present at the disciplinary committee and to make any necessary statements," and added, "Unless there are exceptional circumstances, the employer cannot refuse this." The court further explained, "With the enactment of the Act on the Status and Treatment of Teachers, private school teachers can, just like national or public school teachers, file appeals and initiate administrative lawsuits," and "it is necessary to ensure that the level of procedural rights guaranteed to private school teachers matches that of national and public school teachers."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing