In the Korean Film Industry, Distribution Networks Take Precedence Over Capital

Tax Breaks Alone Won't Open Theater Screens [The Second Take] View original image

The foundations of South Korea’s film creation ecosystem are being shaken. Unless chosen by heavyweight capital, even renowned auteurs find it difficult to launch new works. Director Lee Chang-dong, who has witnessed this firsthand, proposed France's "SOFICA" as an alternative at the Lumière Summit on September 7. This scheme offers individual investors in films an income tax deduction of up to 48% of their investment, serving as an incentive to spur the production of diverse films.


The domestic situation is dire. Although the 3% admission fee surcharge for the Film Development Fund, the Korean Film Council's core funding source, was reinstated, total collections have declined significantly. The fund is barely sustained through transfers from the National Sports Promotion Fund and the Lottery Fund. Currently, mid- and low-budget films are forced to rely on direct government support. This is why proposals to fill the funding gap with private capital seem appealing.


However, a more fundamental problem than capital sourcing is the monopoly over distribution channels. What makes SOFICA effective is not just its tax benefits, but also the legal safeguards underpinning it. In France, even screen monopolies are regulated: no single film can occupy more than 30% of total screens, and multiplexes with 12 or more screens can show a title on only two screens. In Korea, the situation is the exact opposite—multiplexes backed by big capital have complete control over screens. During holidays and peak seasons, one or two blockbuster films can dominate over 60% of all screens. Even if a diverse film is completed with the help of a tax break, it fails to secure theaters, and investors' money vanishes upon release. Investments that do not prove commercial viability risk being abandoned, stirring up debates around tax fairness.


Tax equity is also an issue. In order to grant substantial tax benefits to investors in a particular industry, the measure must be clearly shown to serve the public interest and deliver industrial impact. Otherwise, the motivation to promote films may become diluted and the system could devolve into a tax-saving tool for the wealthy or a channel for high-risk investment. There is also the risk of repeating past failures, when the KIF Fund was funneled to major distributors and large corporate projects, providing mere life support for creators.


Before tax incentives, the distribution bottleneck must be addressed. Institutional measures are needed to limit screen monopolies and to guarantee at least a minimum opportunity for mid- and low-budget films to reach audiences. While the 2019 controversy over "Avengers: Endgame"—which at one time occupied 79.3% of screens—highlighted this issue, relevant legislation failed to pass in the National Assembly. Monopoly of screens by particular films remains a persistent problem.


There is also a need to diversify the ways in which private capital is attracted. Rather than granting large-scale tax benefits to individuals, it is worth considering linking corporate ESG (Environment, Social, Governance) management and cultural investment. Steering large companies’ social contribution funds toward diversity film investments and connecting these to tax incentives can help attract stable institutional capital while reducing criticism of tax cuts for the wealthy.


Government support should also trigger a mandatory link to the proportion of intellectual property (IP) rights retained. Even when blockbusters like "Squid Game" create trillions of won in value, Korean production companies, after relinquishing copyright, earn only a subcontractor's margin of around 10%. State finances should not be used to prop up such a structure. Projects involving bulk licensing that merely enrich overseas platforms should be excluded from support. Instead, resources and tax incentives should be focused on projects where Korean production companies fully own the IP and can return derivative profits to the domestic market.



Introducing SOFICA simply for its tax benefits, without legal protections, would be a misguided attempt to transplant a foreign system unsuited to local circumstances—a mirage. Building a fair distribution network and robust barriers to protect copyright must be top national priorities. Without fundamentally overhauling the ecosystem, a dazzling renaissance for Korean cinema will end in tragedy. Korea must abandon sentimental appeals and embark on structural reform driven by harsh industrial logic.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing