Struggling with “One Prosecutor for Two Court Panels”

Politicians Demand “Cut Prosecution Office Staffing to One-Third”

Front-Line Prosecutors: “Warrant Reviews and Case Dispositions Remain Unchanged”

"Reduce Prosecutors" Pushes Prosecution Office to the Brink... Field Fears Collapse of Prosecutions, Surge in Unresolved Cases View original image

With the abolition of the prosecution office scheduled for October, pressure to drastically reduce the number of prosecutors at the newly established Public Prosecution Office is intensifying, led by the Democratic Party. As a result, prosecutors who have decided to work at the Public Prosecution Office are facing growing concerns. Even if direct investigative authority is removed from the prosecution, the core functions of the prosecution as an accusatory agency will remain. There are concerns that a sharp reduction in the number of prosecutors at the Public Prosecution Office could lead to the ‘collapse of indictment maintenance’ in key public cases.


According to the legal community on September 10, the draft organizational structure for the Public Prosecution Office, which will open on October 2, includes a plan to maintain the current number of prosecutors at 2,292. However, hardliners such as Assemblyman Jeong Cheongrae and Assemblyman Lee Seongyun are demanding that the number be cut to one-third, and have called for amendments to the draft. In addition, Minister of the Interior and Safety Yoon Hojoong has stated that “revisions to the draft are under consideration,” further amplifying the pressure to downsize the Public Prosecution Office.


The mood among field prosecutors is quite different. That is because, although ‘direct summons investigations’ will be eliminated due to the conversion to the Public Prosecution Office, the core prosecutorial tasks remain unchanged. One deputy chief prosecutor said, “Even if it becomes the Public Prosecution Office, practical work such as pre-detention interviews with suspects, reviewing mountains of case records, and making prosecution decisions—where prosecutors spend their whole day—will remain the same.”


Moreover, the complexity of tasks in the 'pre-indictment phase' is actually increasing. This includes reviewing warrants competitively requested by multiple investigative agencies—the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency, the National Investigation Headquarters, and the National Police Agency—and requiring thorough supplementary investigations before filing charges. One chief prosecutor noted, “Since investigations inherently restrict fundamental rights, prosecutors at the Public Prosecution Office serve the essential role of ensuring due process and protecting human rights. If the number of personnel is reduced, the time spent reviewing each case will decrease, unfinished cases will pile up, and if the focus shifts solely to processing speed, the result will inevitably be inadequate reviews.”

"Reduce Prosecutors" Pushes Prosecution Office to the Brink... Field Fears Collapse of Prosecutions, Surge in Unresolved Cases View original image

There is also a sense of crisis that reducing manpower will fundamentally undermine the ability to handle trials. Over the past 10 years, the number of court divisions has surged by 32%, but the number of trial prosecutors assigned to courtrooms has increased by only 20%. While the number of judges has grown, the number of prosecutors has been frozen for 12 years, resulting in the ratio of prosecutors to judges (64%) dropping to the lowest level in history. A frontline trial prosecutor said, “One trial prosecutor is currently responsible for two court divisions, appearing in court four times a week. It is physically impossible to thoroughly review records or prepare for witness examinations.” This shortage of personnel for trial work has led directly to a surge in unfinished cases. In combination with the dispatch of prosecutors to special investigations and the exodus of personnel, there has been a 23% drop in active prosecutors over the past four years, while the average number of unfinished cases per prosecutor has soared by 310% (from 53.9 cases in 2022 to 221.4 cases as of July this year).


Some in politics criticize the newly established 'Judicial Control Department' in each local Public Prosecution Office as a “trick” to keep the police under constant supervision. However, those in the field largely view it as the last safeguard to prevent a repeat of past high-profile cases such as the Jang Yoongi and Jang Miran cases, as well as the only means to oversee cases dropped by the police. Further concerns arise if prosecution investigators are transferred en masse to the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency. For example, if approximately 1,600 investigators move to that agency, the remaining 4,700 personnel at the Public Prosecution Office would be forced to shoulder the additional workload, creating an abnormal structure. One senior prosecutor said, “If staff numbers are drastically cut simply because a team is being closed, those left will be overwhelmed and unable to handle core functions such as victim support, mandatory notifications, and managing vast amounts of electronic records.”



In response to suspicions from some political circles that downsizing will lead to abuse of investigative powers, another senior prosecutor stated, “It is unreasonable to assume that simply having more personnel at the Public Prosecution Office will lead to abuse of direct investigative authority, which is already banned by law. Rather than a drastic reduction in staff, it is essential for the remaining prosecutors to properly fulfill the core responsibilities of an accusatory agency—judicial oversight, maintaining prosecutions, and representing the public interest.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing