Decision Documents to Be Sent for Non-Prosecution... Prosecutors May Request Unlimited Reinvestigations
Police Amend Crime Investigation Rules in Response to Criminal Procedure Act Reform
Prosecutors’ Oversight Strengthened; Expanded Protection for Parties Involved
The police have prepared amendments to the Police Investigation Rules and the Crime Investigation Rules ahead of changes to the criminal justice system. In an effort to further protect the rights and interests of parties involved in cases, the police will now send the entire decision document when a non-prosecution decision is made to allow parties to clearly understand the reasoning. In addition, prosecutors will be able to request reinvestigations without limitation. This means that both responsibility and accountability for the police will increase.
The National Police Agency announced on September 10 that it has drawn up amendments to the Police Investigation Rules and Crime Investigation Rules, syncing with the implementation of the revised Criminal Procedure Act and the regulations on mutual cooperation and general investigation standards between prosecutors and judicial police officers (Investigation Standards).
These amendments are designed to specify the new Criminal Procedure Act provisions, which focus on separating investigation and prosecution. While there are concerns that additional oversight mechanisms for police investigations could lead to delays in investigations, the police have explained that their priority has been to enhance the fairness and accountability of investigations.
First, under the separation of investigation and prosecution, the roles are clearly divided: the prosecutor is responsible for bringing and maintaining public prosecutions, while judicial police officers under the National Police Agency or the Serious Crime Investigation Agency are responsible for investigations. Additionally, the scope of judicial police officers, previously set as those from inspector to superintendent general, has now been updated to include all ranks inspector and above. Provisions that remained from previous investigation authority adjustments, which assumed prosecutorial command over the police, have also been brought in line with current practice.
The most contentious topic is supplementary investigations. From now on, the police will, in principle, be required to complete supplementary investigations requested by prosecutors within one month. This period, sharply reduced from the previous three months, can be exceptionally extended within one further month with a request to the prosecutor. Previously, only the outcomes of supplementary investigations were reported, but now both investigation results and case records must be sent in advance to the prosecutor, so the prosecutor's opinions can be incorporated, reinforcing the process.
Requests for corrective measures and reinvestigations are also being strengthened. If concerns about human rights violations arise during investigations, prosecutors may request corrective measures at any time. If these are not carried out, prosecutors may demand the case be forwarded or transferred to another investigative body. Notably, prosecutors may request reinvestigation in cases where the police have decided not to refer the case for prosecution, and the one-time limit on such requests will be abolished, meaning prosecutors may request reinvestigation as often as they deem necessary.
Prosecutors will also be effectively granted the authority to conduct factual inquiries. While direct investigative powers will be abolished, they will be given a new "fact-finding authority". Prosecutors may gather information from parties involved in the case and suspects, or request information from public offices as necessary to decide whether to file charges or request a reinvestigation. While statements and data obtained this way will not carry evidentiary power, they may be appended to case records for reference.
Additionally, the police have focused on guaranteeing the rights and interests of all parties involved in a case. Police officers receiving all reports or complaints must decide whether to refer a case within three months to prevent investigation delays. Complainants and others will be entitled to request an interview to present their views to the prosecutor, and when the police issue a non-prosecution decision, the full decision and appeal forms will be sent. The scope of those with appeal rights will also be expanded: in addition to complainants and victims, those who have direct interests equivalent to victims, such as accusers alleging false accusations, will also be entitled to appeal.
The standard for determining investigative jurisdiction when prosecutors and police both seek warrants, which was based on the timing of warrant applications, will be abolished. If concurrent jurisdiction occurs with the Serious Crime Investigation Agency, issues will be resolved via an "Investigation Jurisdiction Coordination Council".
The Serious Crime Investigation Agency, which will handle six categories of major crimes, has established case allocation standards based on the scope of economic offenses such as fraud and embezzlement, using the Act on the Aggravated Punishment of Specific Economic Crimes to define offenses involving damages of 500 million won or more. However, if additional charges are identified or damages increase during a police investigation, conflict may arise between the police, who have already advanced the investigation, and the Serious Crime Investigation Agency, which may request transfer. Such disputes will be resolved through the Investigation Jurisdiction Coordination Council.
In principle, if the Serious Crime Investigation Agency requests case transfer, the police must comply. Even if the police discover intelligence or launch an investigation into a crime within the major crime categories, all cases must be reported to the Serious Crime Investigation Agency at the point of recognition (upon case initiation). Conversely, the police will not have any similar authority to request transfers and, in effect, will be tasked with handling virtually all cases. This raises concerns about selective investigations by the Serious Crime Investigation Agency.
An official at the National Police Agency stated, "Since the Serious Crime Investigation Agency does not report back to the police, it can essentially select which cases it wishes to take." The official added, "At the same time, for major crimes, there is also an element of cross-checking between the police and the Serious Crime Investigation Agency. Overall, the system has been designed to give the Serious Crime Investigation Agency priority and, from the police's perspective, this means that the agency will serve as a check on the police as well."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim Jongcheol, Acting Commissioner General of the National Police Agency, said, "These amendments are meant to refine investigation procedures under the new criminal justice system and specify the details of cooperation between agencies and ensure the fairness of investigations," adding, "We will take the necessary steps and follow-up measures to ensure the new system is established smoothly."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.