When US West Coast Freight Rates Fluctuate Fourfold, Korea–Japan Moves Just 1.4 Times... The Secret Lies in Busan Port
68% of Korea–Japan Cargo Is Transshipment...
Busan-Centric Feeder Network Acts as a Buffer
Korean Carriers Operate 80% of the Korea–Japan Route
Collaboration Among Short-Sea Lines Ensures Continued Stability
Amid global fluctuations in the container shipping market caused by oversupply and geopolitical risks, the Korea–Japan route has maintained relatively stable freight rates. Analysts attribute this stability to the high proportion—nearly 70%—of transshipment cargo passing through Busan Port, as well as a route operation structure led by Korean-flagged short-sea carriers and strong cooperation among shipping lines, all of which serve to reduce freight rate volatility.
According to the Korea Ocean Business Corporation on September 10, an analysis of freight rates based on the corporation's Korea Container Composite Index (KCCI) from January 2, 2024, to August of this year showed that the weekly volatility for the US West Coast route (KUWI) stood at 7.59%. By contrast, the Korea–Japan route (KJI) recorded a volatility of only 1.39%.
There was also a pronounced difference in the gap between the highest and lowest freight rates. During the same period, the difference on the US West Coast route reached 4.34 times the lowest level, whereas the gap for the Korea–Japan route was held to just 1.42 times. This means that while the Korea–Japan route's rates also fluctuated in line with the global shipping market, the scale of these fluctuations was relatively limited.
The transshipment network centered on Busan Port is cited as a key driver of this stability. In the first half of this year, total bilateral cargo volume between Korea and Japan amounted to 1.12 million TEU, of which approximately 68% was transshipment cargo. This indicates that the Korea–Japan route does not merely serve as a short-distance channel for Korea-Japan import and export cargo—it also functions as a 'feeder network' connecting Busan Port to global long-haul routes.
Japan's port structure is another factor boosting Busan Port's competitiveness in transshipment. Cargo in Japan is dispersed among the five major ports—Tokyo, Osaka, Kobe, Nagoya, and Yokohama—as well as numerous regional ports. According to the Korea Ocean Business Corporation, transshipping cargo from Japan's regional ports through Busan is up to 30% more cost-effective than first moving it to a major Japanese port and then loading it onto an ocean-going vessel. Busan's dense sailing schedule and wide range of services are also seen as major reasons why Japanese shippers increasingly opt for Busan Port.
The shift to Korean-flagged carriers playing a central role in the Korea–Japan route has also had a significant impact. Japan’s NYK, MOL, and K-Line responded to the global shipping downturn of the 2010s by integrating their container businesses and launching ONE. Since then, Japanese shipping companies have concentrated their capacity on long-haul routes, with around 80% of Korea–Japan operations now handled by Korean carriers. HMM, for example, currently does not allocate its own vessels to direct Korea–Japan services and instead transports Japanese-bound transshipment cargo via slots within its alliances or through feeder contracts with domestic short-sea carriers.
Trend of Freight Indices for the US West Coast and Korea-Japan Shipping Routes. Korea Marine Transport Promotion Corporation.
View original imageThis has contributed to the expansion of Busan Port. Annual container throughput at Busan has reached 24.4 million TEU, ranking seventh in the world and surpassing the combined total of 15.62 million TEU at Japan’s five major ports. The concentration of transshipment volume at Busan has led to more frequent service offerings and enhanced competitiveness, creating a virtuous cycle that attracts even more cargo.
The cooperation system among Korean short-sea carriers also helps limit abrupt freight rate swings. The 11 member lines of the Korea Near-Sea Freight Council (KNFC) optimize capacity based on market conditions to maintain supply-demand balance. In addition, the high proportion of transshipment cargo and long-term contracts with major shipping lines serve as a buffer to absorb short-term freight rate shocks originating from long-haul routes.
However, low freight rate volatility does not always equate to greater profitability for carriers. While stable rates make it easier to predict future performance, they also limit opportunities for companies to maximize profits during periods of sharp rate increases. The Korea–Japan route, in particular, offers lower baseline rates than long-haul routes, which is one reason major Japanese carriers are not actively competing on this corridor.
The Korea Ocean Business Corporation noted that as the global shipping market’s cycles become shorter and geopolitical uncertainty increases, proactive strategies are needed to maintain current stability. It also pointed out that cooperation systems among shipping lines, just like past agreements such as the Transpacific Stabilization Agreement (TSA) and Far East Freight Conference (FEFC) that have since been dissolved, will need to be adjusted to reflect changes in regulatory environments.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
A representative from the Korea Ocean Business Corporation commented, "The Korea–Japan route is more than just a trade link between two countries; it plays a core role as a global feeder network centered on Busan Port. It is now time to seek sustainable growth strategies in line with the changing global environment, leveraging the unique market structure and cooperation framework that have established differentiated stability."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.