With the Blue House having rejected the nomination of a new Supreme Court justice to succeed former Supreme Court Justice Noh Tae-ak, the legal community is now focused on the next move of Chief Justice Cho Hui-dae (13th class of the Judicial Research and Training Institute). According to a Legal Times investigation, Chief Justice Cho is strongly considering convening the Justice Recommendation Committee again to restart the recommendation process and renominating a Supreme Court justice candidate. This is essentially the only method that aligns with the Court Organization Act.


Article 41-2, Paragraph 8 of the Court Organization Act stipulates that the Justice Recommendation Committee is regarded as disbanded once it has recommended a candidate. Accordingly, the prevailing interpretation is that the previous committee, which recommended four judges including Judge Son Bong-gi of the Daegu District Court to Chief Justice Cho, was dissolved on January 21, 2026, following the recommendations.


As the recommendation and nomination process was concluded once, the consensus is that, for a renomination, the recommendation committee must be reconvened and the candidate recommendation process must begin anew.


A presiding judge from a local court commented, "The recommendation committee is merely an advisory body to support the Chief Justice in the nomination process; it is not a body that binds the Chief Justice. That is why the Court Organization Act only states that the Chief Justice 'respects' the committee’s recommendations."


He went on to say, "If the president excludes recommended candidates by rejecting the nomination and in effect leaves only a specific candidate, this would undermine the constitutional nomination power of the Chief Justice, thereby violating the Constitution and the law."


A judge from the High Court also stated, "Since the Chief Justice has already exercised the nomination power, the role of the previous committee has ended. Forming a new recommendation committee therefore complies with the law."


Similarly, 40 legal professionals from the 17th class of the Judicial Research and Training Institute (as of September 7), 84 from the 14th class, and 27 alumni from the Seoul National University Law School class of 1976 issued consecutive statements urging respect for the Chief Justice’s nomination authority.


With the Blue House declining to accept Chief Justice Cho’s nomination of a successor to former Supreme Court Justice Noh Tae-ak on August 18, it is expected that two Supreme Court justice seats will remain vacant for the time being. The confirmation hearing for Kim Seong-su (24th class), the candidate nominated to succeed former Supreme Court Justice Lee Heung-gu, who retired on September 7, is scheduled for September 14.



Park Suyeon, Legal Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing