CIO Opposes Prosecution Office's Request for Supplementary Investigation
Calls for Separate Procedure of "Requesting Additional Investigation"
In Cases Where CIO Lacks Indictment Authority,
Final Decision to Prosecute Lies with the Prosecut

Controversy is mounting over whether the Corruption Investigation Office for High-Ranking Officials (CIO) should handle cases differently from other investigative agencies, even in cases where it lacks prosecutorial authority, as it opposes the Prosecution Service’s prosecutors’ requests for supplementary investigations. While the CIO claims that “prosecutor-to-prosecutor” relations are horizontal and insists on a separate procedure for requesting additional investigations, there is criticism that investigative completeness should take precedence over institutional status, especially as the CIO itself acknowledges the need for further investigation.

The Corruption Investigation Office for High-Ranking Officials, which has reissued an arrest warrant for President Yoon Suk-yeol, is continuing to deliberate on the timing of re-execution. On the 10th, the appearance of the Corruption Investigation Office for High-Ranking Officials at the Government Complex Gwacheon in Gyeonggi Province.

The Corruption Investigation Office for High-Ranking Officials, which has reissued an arrest warrant for President Yoon Suk-yeol, is continuing to deliberate on the timing of re-execution. On the 10th, the appearance of the Corruption Investigation Office for High-Ranking Officials at the Government Complex Gwacheon in Gyeonggi Province.

View original image

According to legal sources on September 9, the CIO recently expressed its opposition to allowing prosecutors of the Prosecution Service to request supplementary investigations from CIO prosecutors. At a regular briefing on September 1, the CIO explained, “It is inappropriate for prosecutors to request supplementary investigations from each other as if dealing with judicial police officers.” Instead, the CIO argued that if the Prosecution Service determines that additional investigation is necessary, there should be a separate procedure for the Prosecution Service to formally request an additional investigation from the CIO.


The issue is that the CIO does not hold prosecutorial authority over every case. In cases where the CIO only investigates and then hands the case over to the Prosecution Service, it is the Prosecutor’s Office that handles whether to indict and maintains the prosecution. Furthermore, starting October 2, the ability of prosecutors from the Prosecution Service to directly conduct supplementary investigations is set to be abolished. Consequently, even if the investigative records handed over by the CIO are insufficient, the Prosecution Service will not be able to supplement them directly.


Another point of contention is how the practical differences between the CIO’s proposed “request for additional investigation” and a “request for supplementary investigation” will be defined. Under the amended Criminal Procedure Act, a request for supplementary investigation comes with procedural requirements such as deadlines for compliance and notification of results. In contrast, a new system for requesting additional investigations would require separate design for obligations to comply and measures in cases of refusal.


This issue has already materialized in practice. In a high-profile bribery case involving a former senior Audit and Inspection Board official, where about 1.58 billion won was at stake, the Prosecution Service asked the CIO to conduct a supplementary investigation. However, the CIO refused, stating that there was no legal basis for such a request. As the courts restricted the Prosecution Service’s direct supplementary investigative authority, only approximately 290 million won worth of charges were ultimately prosecuted, with the remaining allegations dropped.



Lee Geunwoo, a professor of law at Gachon University, commented, “When the CIO prosecutes a case itself, it can take responsibility for the investigation’s outcome. However, there is no reason to treat cases differently from other investigative agencies simply because the Prosecution Service handles the prosecution after the CIO’s investigation. The priority right now is not institutional pride but establishing a system that ensures investigations are completed and prosecutions are properly carried out.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing