[Each to Their Own JR Global REIT] ① Defeat in UK... Debt Restructuring Talks Enter Full Swing
"Cash Trap Valid" Ruling Sets Repayment Start for December Next Year
Seoul Bankruptcy Court Appoints Samil PricewaterhouseCoopers as Examiner
KRW 600 Billion Debt Restructuring and Five-Year Repayment Plan Review in Full Swing
JR Global REIT, the first listed REIT in Korea to file for corporate rehabilitation proceedings, has lost its UK lawsuit related to the appraisal of Brussels Finance Tower. On September 8 (local time), the Commercial Court of the High Court of Justice in England ruled that the appraisal—which prompted the creditor group to trigger a cash trap—was valid according to the loan agreement.
JR Global REIT, the first domestic listed REIT to file for corporate rehabilitation proceedings, has lost a lawsuit in the UK related to the appraisal of Brussels Finance Tower. Photo by Getty Images
View original imageAs a result, the five-year repayment plan proposed by JR Global REIT to creditors will again be subject to external review, this time based on a scenario where the start of repayments is delayed and funding pressure increases. The Seoul Bankruptcy Court has appointed Samil PricewaterhouseCoopers as examiner and has initiated an external review of the company’s going-concern value and its repayment plan.
UK Ruling: "Appraisal Was Inadequate, But Not Manipulated For a Predetermined Outcome"
The lawsuit arose after Jones Lang LaSalle (JLL), commissioned by the creditor group, appraised the Finance Tower at 920 million euros. This valuation caused the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio to exceed the contract threshold of 52.5%, which triggered a cash trap preventing local rental income from being repatriated to Korea. JR Global REIT argued that the creditor group had interfered in the appraisal process to understate the asset’s value, and filed a lawsuit against the agent bank, CBRE Loan Services.
The court acknowledged that some creditors had wanted the appraisal below 950 million euros and that JLL may have been aware of this towards the end of the process. However, the court determined there was no undue pressure to reach a specific valuation, nor did JLL lose its independence.
There was also criticism of JLL’s appraisal process itself. The court pointed out that the cross-verification using discounted cash flow analysis was superficial and that some crucial issues were not adequately addressed. It also noted that the lead appraiser may not have fully grasped the significance of the results of his work.
However, the court concluded that these problems alone were not enough to invalidate the appraisal. While the assessment was not of the highest standard, it at least met the contractual requirements, and there was no evidence that the process had been manipulated for a specific result in advance.
Repayments Now Set for December Next Year... Repayment Burden Grows
The most immediate impact of the loss is on the payment schedule. According to the company’s published plan, if it had won the lawsuit, JR Global REIT would have started paying interest in March next year and principal from June. Since it lost, principal and interest payments will begin from December next year, following the refinancing of the Finance Tower secured loan.
Financial burdens have also increased. In the event of a win, only part of the 144.6 billion won proceeds from the Manhattan office sale would have been used to pay off the Belgian asset. Now, the entire amount must go toward repaying the local senior loan. The amount required in next year’s refinancing will also increase from 171 billion won to 283.7 billion won.
The key assumption is that Finance Tower’s value will be appraised at 1.1 billion euros next year. As the latest ruling rejected the company’s attempt to invalidate the earlier appraisal of 920 million euros, which is the basis for the current cash trap, the justification for assuming a large-scale refinancing based on next year’s 1.1 billion-euro valuation will now itself need to be reviewed.
However, the burden of foreign exchange hedging has eased considerably. On September 4, the company announced that, by terminating some currency hedging contracts related to JR No.26 REIT and JR No.28 REIT ahead of schedule, the relevant debt—which stood at about 165 billion won at the time of the rehabilitation filing—had decreased to around 44.3 billion won at the current exchange rate. This took advantage of currency appreciation to reduce future settlement obligations.
Korean Court Initiates Verification of Five-Year Repayment Plan
The domestic rehabilitation process has now entered full-scale examination. The 18th division of the Seoul Bankruptcy Court (Presiding Judge Yang Minho) has recently appointed Samil PricewaterhouseCoopers as examiner. The review will cover whether the company’s going-concern value exceeds its liquidation value and whether proceeding with rehabilitation is appropriate. The interim report is due by September 28.
Lee Jeongyeop, a former presiding judge at the Seoul Bankruptcy Court and now CEO of Lawjibsa LLC, commented, “A pre-commencement examination is a procedure to verify whether liquidation would be preferable to rehabilitation,” adding, “It also reflects the judgment that it is no longer viable to simply wait for voluntary negotiations.”
The Seoul Bankruptcy Court has extended the period for the Autonomous Restructuring Support (ARS), which allows the company and creditors to negotiate voluntary settlements, until September 14. As the deadline for the examiner’s report is after this date, there is a possibility that the negotiation period may be extended once again.
Negotiations remain highly challenging. At the time of the rehabilitation filing, the list of creditors included about 165 billion won in forex hedge-related debt, 321 billion won in publicly-offered corporate bonds, 59.2 billion won in privately-placed bonds, and 55.4 billion won in loan debt—bringing total obligations to over 600 billion won. The company’s proposal is to repay these liabilities in installments by 2031.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
There are also more than 28,000 minority shareholders as of the end of last year, who are both shareholders and creditors owed 22.7 billion won in unpaid dividends. The interests of holders of publicly-offered corporate bonds, forex hedge liabilities, privately-placed bondholders, and loan creditors all differ. Ultimately, the key question is whether creditors will accept the company’s proposed five-year plan. While the UK lawsuit has concluded, substantive negotiations around JR Global REIT are now only just beginning.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.