<M&A, Deals That Change a Company's Fate> Seminar Announcement Photo (Photo by C&G Forum)

Seminar Announcement Photo (Photo by C&G Forum)

View original image

'C&G Forum,' a research group specializing in corporate governance and management rights (chaired by Professor Kim Min-ki of KAIST), announced that it held a regular seminar on September 7 under the theme of "M&A, The Deal That Changes a Company's Destiny."


This seminar was organized to examine key drivers of the domestic M&A market—such as the three major low-cost coffee chains and the recent Korea Zinc case—and to discuss the importance of successful deal structuring and sale strategies.


Attendees included Professor Kim Min-ki of the Department of Industrial & Systems Engineering at KAIST, Kim Heekyung, Managing Partner at Law Firm Doyoung, Professor Ahn Sungjin of the School of Business at Ewha Womans University, Yoo Hyosang, President of the Unicorn Management Economics Research Institute, Professor Lee Hwa-ryeong of the Department of Economics at Sejong University, Professor Jeong Seung-hwan of the School of Business at Yonsei University, Professor Chun Jin-suk of the Department of Business Administration at Sungkyunkwan University, and Professor Han Juhun of the Department of Industrial & Systems Engineering at KAIST.


Kim Heekyung, Managing Partner at Law Firm Doyoung, who gave the keynote speech, highlighted the different exit strategies of the three low-cost coffee franchise operators—Mega Coffee, Compose Coffee, and Paikdabang—and emphasized the importance of M&A from the sell-side perspective. She noted, "Given the inheritance tax, which can reach up to 60% with majority shareholder premium, as well as the extremely narrow window for IPO, M&A is the most realistic exit strategy to convert a lifelong business into reliable cash." She added, "Even for deals involving the same amount, how the deal structure controls risk factors such as taxes, hidden liabilities (contingent debts), and differing value assessments is the true battleground."


In addition, Attorney Kim analyzed the recent management rights dispute at Korea Zinc from the perspective of M&A deal structure, stating, "Based on the management cooperation agreement clauses currently released to the public between Young Poong and MBK Partners, the structure allows MBK to secure voting rights and potentially exercise a call option in the future. This suggests that Young Poong was not trying to maintain control, but was aiming for an exit with a control premium." She added, "Unlike in the U.S. with poison pills or in the UK with mandatory tender offer rules, the absence of predetermined obligations and deadlines has led to more than 24 civil and criminal lawsuits and injunctions, amounting to an endless, wasteful game of chicken. As a result, Korea Zinc shareholders are shouldering the enormous costs of a poorly designed, failed deal that was actually crafted for MBK."


The ensuing panel discussion delved deeply into the realities and institutional limitations of Korea's M&A market. Regarding the Korea Zinc case, Professor Chun Jin-suk remarked, "This is deteriorating into an emotional battle with no escape route for either side, far beyond justifiable economic profit," urging a prompt resolution of the conflict. President Yoo Hyosang commented, "If Korea had established a mandatory tender offer system—like that in the UK or Japan, requiring the acquisition of all remaining shares after reaching a certain stake—reckless stake accumulation and wasteful competition that exploit institutional loopholes, as seen in this incident, would not have occurred."


President Yoo further pointed out, "Given that only a tiny fraction of Korean startups actually succeed in listing, M&A is not a choice but an essential survival exit strategy." Professor Jeong Seung-hwan added, "As seen in the case of low-cost coffee sales, the completeness of internal systems such as CRM and whether a global strategic investor (SI) is attracted can create several-fold differences in corporate value, making thorough preparation indispensable for both sellers and buyers."


Ultimately, the current role of M&A appears to go beyond realizing short-term gains, serving as a key engine for improving the overall structure of Korea's industrial ecosystem and enhancing capital efficiency.



Participants on the day voiced strong agreement that, unlike in the U.S. (with poison pill provisions) or the UK (with mandatory tender offers), the Korean capital market lacks clear rules to regulate control contests in advance. They called for the swift establishment of relevant legal guidelines and institutional improvements to prevent wasteful disputes and foster a healthy M&A ecosystem.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing