First Trial Ruling on Smilegate Founder Hyukbin Kwon’s Divorce Lawsuit Set for September 9

The verdict for the divorce and asset division lawsuit involving Hyukbin Kwon, founder and Chief Visionary Officer (CVO) of gaming company Smilegate, will be delivered at 2 p.m. on September 9 at the Seoul Family Court. This marks the court’s first ruling nearly four years after Mr. Kwon’s spouse, identified as Ms. Lee, filed the lawsuit in November 2022. The trial has drawn public attention because the scale of asset division could reach up to 4 trillion won. Depending on the court’s decision, the ownership structure of Smilegate Group—which has been maintained as a 100% single-owner entity—may be affected.


Hyukbin Kwon, Founder and Chief Visionary Officer (CVO) of Smilegate. Photo by Yonhap News.

Hyukbin Kwon, Founder and Chief Visionary Officer (CVO) of Smilegate. Photo by Yonhap News.

View original image


While Mr. Kwon maintains that he does not wish to divorce, he cannot rule out the possibility that the divorce petition might be granted. In this case, the size of the asset division will depend on whether Ms. Lee’s contribution to the company during its early days is recognized, as well as on the timing of the corporate valuation. According to the court’s calculation using the discounted cash flow method, the future value of Smilegate is estimated at 8.016 trillion won. Based on a simple calculation of half that amount, the portion Ms. Lee is claiming would total 4.008 trillion won.


Ms. Lee contends that Smilegate was founded after their marriage, that she contributed as a co-founder—including serving as CEO with an initial 30% equity stake—and is therefore demanding half of the shares. In response, Mr. Kwon’s side argues that Ms. Lee did not make a substantial capital contribution nor actively participate in management. They further emphasize that the company’s value rose significantly, particularly with the commercial success of "Crossfire" and "Lost Ark," only after Ms. Lee withdrew as a registered director in 2005.


The gaming industry is closely monitoring whether the lawsuit’s outcome will have broader implications for Smilegate Group as an unlisted company, beyond simply affecting the private division of assets. Although the core game services are not expected to be directly disrupted, there is a possibility that changes in company operations may occur.


If the court orders a division of shares in-kind, resulting in Ms. Lee holding part of the ownership, the single-owner fast decision-making structure could be impacted. There would also be potential for the dispute to escalate into a management rights conflict. However, it is considered more likely that the court will order a cash settlement, taking business stability into account.


If the ordered cash payout amounts to several trillion won, this would pose a financial burden for Mr. Kwon, given that the majority of his assets are tied up in unlisted stock. In this scenario, he would need to sell shares or receive an extraordinarily large dividend in order to raise cash within a short period. Consequently, some observers speculate that an initial public offering (IPO) may become an unavoidable consideration.


Smilegate is drawing a line between the founder’s personal matters and corporate concerns amid various negative speculations and concerns. The company has emphasized that even if asset division is granted and the shareholding structure changes, this does not mean an immediate loss of management rights or the splitting up of the company.


A company official stated, "Even if the court rules for an in-kind division of some shares, there will be no change to the current major shareholder’s stable exercise of management rights. The company will continue to focus on game development and revenue growth as before." The official also clarified, "The 8 trillion won figure is simply the highest figure out of six different valuation methods the court used to assess Smilegate Holdings, an unlisted company. This does not mean Mr. Kwon has been ordered to pay that amount."



In addition, Smilegate stated that there are currently no plans for an IPO. As this is only a first-instance ruling, it is expected that both sides may contest the verdict, leading to a prolonged legal battle.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing