Six-Month Prison Sentence Suspended for One Year Finalized

The Supreme Court has ruled that if a nursing home facility manager fails to ensure that the two-person transfer guideline is observed for residents at high risk of falls, the manager can be held liable for occupational negligence resulting in death.

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

According to the legal community on September 4, the First Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Ma Yongju) recently dismissed the appeal of nursing home manager A, who was indicted on charges of occupational negligence resulting in death, and upheld the original ruling sentencing A to six months in prison, suspended for one year.


On June 8, 2023, caregiver B at a nursing home in Jung-gu, Incheon, attempted to move resident C, a woman in her nineties with osteoporosis and limited mobility in her lower body, for a bath. B failed to follow the two-person transfer guideline, attempted to lift C alone, and caused her to slip off the bed, resulting in a femoral fracture. C died on June 17 of the same year due to embolism, a complication from the fracture.


A was also brought to trial on charges of failing to establish an effective management and supervision system regarding two-person transfers and fall prevention among caregivers, and not taking emergency transportation measures in accordance with guidelines after receiving a report about the accident in the evening.


The key issue was whether the facility manager has an occupational duty of care to direct and supervise caregivers in fall prevention measures and to take immediate emergency actions such as hospitalizing the resident if an accident occurs.


In the first trial in June of last year, the court sentenced B to one year in prison, suspended for two years, and acquitted A. The court found it difficult to conclude that A had been negligent in management and supervision, and held that even if C had been transported on the day of the accident, the outcome would have been the same due to refusal of surgery. Thus, the court rejected causality between negligence and death. As B did not appeal, the ruling against B became final.


In the second trial, on January 1 of this year, the court accepted the prosecutor’s appeal and sentenced B to six months in prison, suspended for one year. The court stated, "Facility manager A failed to establish an effective management and supervision system to ensure that two-person transfer was performed for high fall risk residents, and is recognized to have neglected the emergency guidelines after the accident."


The court added, "The fact that the victim's family chose not to proceed with surgery is only a factor in mitigating the defendant's liability, but it does not refute the substantial causality between negligence and death."



The Supreme Court also found no error in the lower court’s ruling and dismissed A's final appeal.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing