Appointment of Former Auditor as Chairman and New Auditor Omitted Key Procedures

No Performance Contract; Employee Compensation Decided Internally

"Appointments Must Follow Law and Articles; Responsibility Proven by Evaluation Results"

The Shinan Renewable Energy Foundation, a foundation established by Shinan-gun—the local institution funded by the Greater Jeolla Gwangju Unified Special City—has once again found itself at the center of controversy after it was revealed that the organization failed to properly carry out both executive appointment procedures and performance management obligations.


Shinan-gun has begun procedures to review whether the foundation’s executives neglected their work obligations and is deliberating on whether to dismiss them through the Committee for Review of Operation of Invested and Funded Organizations.

Monument for the Renewable Energy Profit-Sharing System.

Monument for the Renewable Energy Profit-Sharing System.

View original image

Previously, this publication reported that the foundation did not consult with Shinan-gun during the new staff recruitment process, and that the foundation expressed the view “there is no need to consult with the county.” This time, issues regarding executive appointment and the absence of a performance contract have also been confirmed.


According to coverage, last year the foundation’s board of directors approved the extension of certain board members’ terms. However, the foundation did not formally request the Shinan County Governor to officially appoint these executives, effectively extending their tenures solely through the board’s internal resolution.


The executive appointment process on April 30 was also called into question.


The foundation appointed Mr. Cho, a former auditor, as chairman for the vacant position, and Mr. Kwon to the vacant auditor position. However, there have been reports that no related documents were submitted to verify a public recruitment notice, candidate reviews, or the Shinan-gun appointment procedure.


Article 9 of the current Act on the Management of Local Government-Funded Institutions stipulates that, except for ex officio executive positions held by public officials, other executives must be appointed through competitive public recruitment. Should any executive fail to fulfill or neglect their duties, the Committee for Review of Operation may deliberate to dismiss them or request dismissal by the appointing authority.


The ordinance on the establishment and operation of the Shinan Renewable Energy Foundation mandates that the chairman shall be elected by the board of directors. However, before the board can elect the chairman, there must be documents proving the candidate’s legal appointment as a director and evidence of appointment by signature of the county governor.


Shinan-gun has determined that the absence of the governor’s appointment and public recruitment, among other key procedures, constitutes a major and evident defect. It has been reported that they are currently deliberating whether executives were negligent in fulfilling their work obligations.


It was also found that not a single performance contract has ever been executed.


Article 11 of the Act on the Management of Local Government-Funded Institutions stipulates that the head of a local government must sign a performance contract with the head of a funded agency. This contract must specify management goals and compensation to be achieved during the term. The outcome of the performance contract must also be reflected when deciding compensation for the following year.


However, since its founding, the foundation has never signed a performance contract with the Shinan County Governor, and compensation for executives and employees has been decided internally within the foundation, according to investigations.


In addition to setting management goals and compensation without a performance contract, for the 2025 performance review carried out in 2026, the foundation received a “Ra” grade, which is considered low. The overall review of this management performance evaluation has also been released on the foundation’s website.


The foundation has presented extensive business plans such as designation as a renewable energy special zone, creation of energy-independent islands, community participation in development projects, and training of offshore wind power specialists. However, it has been criticized for focusing too heavily on competitive project applications rather than its core founding purpose, and for producing few outcomes that local residents could actually experience.


Whistleblower A stated, “Executives of public institutions are not positions to be distributed at the board’s discretion as needed. All appointments must follow the procedures stipulated by law and articles of incorporation, and responsibility must be demonstrated through clear management goals and the results of performance evaluation.”


A also added, “At the time of the executive’s reappointment and appointment, the foundation should have released the board meeting minutes, public recruitment documents, the request to and appointment by Shinan-gun, performance contracts, grounds for compensation calculations for executives and staff, and its management evaluation improvement plan. Both Shinan-gun and the Shinan County Assembly must not merely hold the foundation responsible, but must also explain their own stewardship for failing to monitor executive appointments and performance contracts to date.”



A further stated, “If a funded institution operated with county residents’ taxes appoints its own executives and decides compensation without performance contracts, this is not independent management but rather unregulated operation. This deliberation on dismissal should not be reduced to a political dispute or the settling of personnel matters from a previous administration. Responsibility must be clarified based on meeting minutes, appointment documents, performance contracts, and management evaluation results.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing