Mokpo University Union Urges Transparent Disclosure of Medical School Selection Process and Evaluation Criteria
Three Main Demands: Disclosure of Both Universities' Proposals, Evaluation Expertise, and More
"Full Verification to Guarantee Regional Healthcare Rights" Signals Ongoing Controversy
The National Mokpo University branch of the University Headquarters of the Korean Government Employees' Union has issued a statement regarding the results of the selection for the university to host Jeonnam National Medical School, calling for the transparent disclosure of the selection process and evaluation criteria.
The union branch at Mokpo University stated, "Given that the long-standing aspiration to establish a national medical school in Jeonnam, which has continued for 36 years, was determined by a mere 1.3-point difference, there must be clear, convincing reasons that can satisfy local residents." The branch then officially announced three major demands: ▲ disclosure of both universities' plans for establishing medical schools; ▲ disclosure of specific evaluation criteria, the results for each item, and the reasoning behind the evaluations; and ▲ thorough verification of the selection process's professionalism, including the composition of the evaluation committee and the time allotted for review.
All appointed professors at Mokpo National University held a press conference on the 1st, criticizing that a poor review process was conducted in the selection of the National Medical University. Photo by Lee Jungkyung
View original imageA union representative emphasized, "The southwest region of Jeonnam is widely comprised of island, farming, and fishing villages, where securing the ‘golden hour at sea’ is directly linked to the right to life," adding, "We will continue to scrutinize the process until the selection institution and related agencies transparently reveal their evaluation criteria to the public, not for the benefit of a particular university, but to guarantee the region's basic right to healthcare."
Amid these union activities, explicit allegations have also emerged from within the university itself, claiming that the evaluation was distorted by an evaluation panel lacking professional expertise, thereby intensifying the controversy surrounding the selection results.
"An Impromptu Committee Formed the Day Before Evaluation... Zero Architecture or Administration Experts"
According to a key official at Mokpo University on September 1, there were significant procedural and professional flaws in the evaluation process for selecting the recommended university for the new medical school.
A Mokpo University official revealed, "The final eight committee members for the evaluation, which took place on August 29, were only confirmed at 6 p.m. on August 28—the day before the evaluation. Of the eight committee members, seven were doctors, and only one was a medical school professor. Furthermore, despite the need to review major hospital construction and administrative procedures involving large budgets and complex permits, not a single architecture expert was included in the panel."
The official continued, "Because there were no experts to rigorously evaluate critical areas such as the construction schedule or the feasibility of establishing a teaching hospital, these areas were essentially glossed over, with both universities receiving virtually identical scores. As a result, the outcome was decided based solely on a few items, such as unverified numbers for securing faculty. We believe our university was effectively robbed during the evaluation process," he said angrily.
The Mokpo University side also sharply criticized the winning proposal from Suncheon National University, arguing that its plan was highly unrealistic. Key problems cited in Suncheon National University's plan included: ▲ the practical impossibility of completing a medical school and university hospital by 2031; ▲ a proposal to use land owned by the local government despite unresolved legal and administrative issues; and ▲ the simple presentation of hiring 140 faculty members without details on the actual candidate pool or resources.
An official pointed out, "Other regions such as Kyungpook National University have also faced challenges because legal restrictions have not been resolved regarding constructing medical school facilities on land owned by local authorities." He added, "By contrast, Mokpo University met the accreditation standard set by KIMEE with 112 personnel and even presented a concrete pool of 160 faculty members, yet lost out to mere inflation of numbers."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The official further stressed, "As an evaluation panel lacking qualifications and expertise was hastily assembled, detailed evaluation items lost their discriminatory power, and the focus shifted to items based on simple numbers, which overturned the results."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.