Press Conference by Administrative Faculty: "Flawed Site Assessment Ignores National Land Ownership"
"1.17-Point Gap in Faculty Recruitment... Disregard for Actual Verification"

All faculty members with administrative positions at Mokpo National University have mounted a full-scale protest, arguing that the selection result for a long-awaited National Medical School project—sought by the region for 36 years—was finalized through a mere 50-minute "blind review process."


On September 1, administrative faculty members at Mokpo National University held an official press conference at the briefing room of the Jeonnam Provincial Government in Gwangju-South Jeolla Special City, strongly criticizing the selection process for the National Medical School as having been conducted with inadequate evaluation.


They particularly pointed out the lack of transparency in the evaluation process, especially as the university was rejected with a slim score difference of just 1.3 points. The professors stated, "A regional wish that has lasted for 36 years should not be decided by a 50-minute assessment. Even minor government projects are not conducted this way," expressing vehement opposition.

All the administrative professors of Mokpo National University held a press conference on the 1st, criticizing that inadequate evaluation occurred during the selection process of the National Medical College. Photo by Lee Jungyung

All the administrative professors of Mokpo National University held a press conference on the 1st, criticizing that inadequate evaluation occurred during the selection process of the National Medical College. Photo by Lee Jungyung

View original image

Issues with Site Verification Assessment... Doubts Over the 1.17-Point Difference in Faculty Recruitment

The professors raised strong objections regarding the certainty of site acquisition assessment (with a weight of 5 points). They highlighted that, although Suncheon National University only presented city-owned land in Suncheon (currently at the MOU stage), Mokpo National University currently owns 50,000 pyeong of national land outright.


They further argued, "It appears that the evaluators assessed our institution's land, which is already owned, the same as Suncheon’s MOU-stage city land." They continued, "If the evaluators or the Jeonnam-Gwangju Institute lacked expertise or understanding about the matter, or if they understood but still graded it this way, it raises a severe issue of fairness."


They also took issue with the faculty recruitment section, which accounted for most of the 1.3-point final difference (specifically, a 1.17-point gap). Mokpo National University stated that it had already secured more than 160 faculty members qualified to be professors for the medical school.


More specifically, Mokpo National University announced its plan to acquire a general hospital and operate it as a temporary teaching hospital, while securing highly qualified faculty members through agreements with university hospital-level facilities in Gwangju. Additionally, Mokpo National University laid out plans to collaborate with three major medical schools in the Seoul metropolitan area to secure outstanding medical education resources.


The professors stressed, "Just from two major hospitals alone, we have already secured more than 160 faculty members qualified as medical school professors. Is there any plan more solid than this?" They added, "We even included an analysis report detailing the 75 faculty-qualified doctors currently employed at the hospital to be acquired." They asserted, "The faculty members to be appointed four years from now should not outweigh the current competition for a medical school site as a decisive factor. The basic principle of project evaluation is to focus on elements that can be objectively verified at present."

Expertise Concerns Over the 50-Minute Review... Regret and Stance Going Forward

What Mokpo National University criticized most harshly was the lack of rigor in the review process itself. The evaluation provided materials to the judges just a day in advance, and the actual process consisted of a 20-minute briefing, 20-minute presentation, and a 30-minute Q&A session.


A Mokpo National University official remarked, "Even for minor government projects, reviewers are brought in a day early to review project proposals together and the main agency explains all relevant regulations and requirements. How can it be fair that a 36-year-long regional priority such as a medical school was handled in this manner?" They also pointed out, "There was even a case where a reviewer was rushed to the meeting at the last minute on the day of evaluation," directly bringing up the issue of the evaluators' expertise.


Faculty members attending the press conference stated they were standing there with deep regret. They expressed their absolute refusal to accept the assessment that the plan, which Mokpo National University prepared meticulously over three years, was considered insufficient.


The university further claimed, "We are confident that, through numerous consulting projects with medical and healthcare infrastructure institutions, we produced the best possible plan that meets the requirements for the establishment and accreditation of a new medical school. The outcome itself indicates a problem with the evaluation process."


Additionally, the university pointed out that Jeonnam-Gwangju Special Metropolitan City had reiterated the strategic importance of Mokpo’s medical school site in plans for a mega-regional healthcare belt, asking, "Is it commonsense that such a strategic plan was overturned in a 50-minute review lacking professionalism?"


The administrative faculty at Mokpo National University emphasized that they could only accept the result if Jeonnam-Gwangju Special Metropolitan City’s claim of a fair and professional review was proven and fully substantiated.


They also reaffirmed their commitment to continue fulfilling their role as members of academia, stating, "We will continue to monitor this region until politics are conducted with trust, every citizen in need is considered, and no one is oppressed by the powerful, so that South Jeolla and the Republic of Korea will become truly just."



This formal statement by Mokpo National University not only voices protest but also sharply raises questions about the transparency and fairness of the evaluation process as a whole. There is a strong likelihood that this will lead to demands for further explanations from the Ministry of Education and local governments.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing