Clashes Over Minimum Service Period, Acting Roles, and Grade 4 Demotions
Governor Lee: "Decisions Made for Organizational Vitality and Work Efficiency"

During the administrative audit of Geochang County Council regarding the regular personnel appointments for the second half of 2026 in Geochang County, Gyeongnam, an intense debate unfolded over the scope of the appointing authority's discretion and whether laws and local regulations had been properly observed.


In particular, Assemblyman Honghee Lee raised a series of questions concerning transfers made without respecting the minimum transfer restriction period, the excessive granting of special approvals, the appointment of a Grade 4 official to the head of a department post equivalent to Grade 5, the assignment of Grade 5 officials as acting directors, and the intensive completion of mandatory learning by some promoted officials. He grilled the administration on the appropriateness of the personnel process.


County Governor Hongki Lee countered, stating, "All appointments were made with the focus on work efficiency and organizational vitality," and denied that there had been any personnel arrangements or pre-promised promotions targeting specific individuals.


[Photo by Geochang County Council] Honghee Lee, member of the Geochang County Council, strongly questioned the governor during the administrative audit, stating that "personnel matters must be conducted within the framework of laws and regulations," urging the governor to ensure the appropriateness of the regular personnel appointments scheduled for the second half of 2026.

[Photo by Geochang County Council] Honghee Lee, member of the Geochang County Council, strongly questioned the governor during the administrative audit, stating that "personnel matters must be conducted within the framework of laws and regulations," urging the governor to ensure the appropriateness of the regular personnel appointments scheduled for the second half of 2026.

View original image

◆ Assemblyman Honghee Lee: "One out of every three transferees has served less than two years"

Assemblyman Honghee Lee presented data showing that, in this round of regular personnel appointments, 71 out of 206 transferees (34.5%) were transferred before completing two years in their current posts.


He revealed that as many as 20 of these officials had served less than one year.


Assemblyman Lee emphasized, "The minimum service period for mandatory posts is a system established to prevent administrative gaps caused by frequent transfers and to ensure job expertise," and questioned whether it could be considered normal when over a third of transferees had served less than two years before being moved.


Governor Lee replied, "While the principle of a minimum period certainly exists, we must take into account local government affairs, organizational circumstances, and the individual's roles and capabilities in a comprehensive manner," adding, "We will strive to comply with the relevant standards to the greatest extent possible going forward."


◆ 88 special approvals... "Have exceptions become the norm?"

Assemblyman Lee also raised issues about exceptions made regarding the mandatory service period. According to the materials he presented, 88 officials—accounting for 42.7% of all transferees—received special approval in this round of personnel appointments.


He asserted, "When special approvals, which are supposed to be applied only in exceptional cases, are granted to nearly half of all transferees, doesn't that mean that exceptions have in effect become the norm?" He demanded submission of the Personnel Committee's review materials for the 88 cases and the specific grounds for each special approval.


Governor Lee explained, "These were items submitted to and approved by the Personnel Committee," and added, "Rather than an abuse of appointing authority, our decisions were centered on revitalizing the organization and on work."


◆ Appointing a Grade 4 official as a Grade 5 department head... "Is there a legal basis?"

The biggest controversy surrounded the appointment of a Grade 4 official as head of the Geochang Incident Office—a position equivalent to Grade 5.


Assemblyman Lee pointed out that, per Geochang County ordinances and enforcement rules, the position of head of the Geochang Incident Office is stipulated to be at the level of section chief (Grade 5). He pressed, "What is the legal basis for assigning a Grade 4 official to a post equivalent to Grade 5?"


Furthermore, he contended, "When a Grade 4 official who used to oversee multiple departments as a bureau chief is moved to head an office equivalent to Grade 5, it can be seen as a practical demotion," and pressed the administration regarding the appropriateness of such a decision.


Governor Lee responded, "We assigned someone with the necessary experience and expertise to properly handle tasks related to the Geochang Incident. The aim is to get the work done."


Assemblyman Lee retorted, "Even if the appointment is made to get the job done, you must abide by the law and regulations first. If necessary, shouldn't ordinances and enforcement rules be revised first before making such personnel decisions?"


◆ Suspicions of 'retaliatory personnel measures'... Governor Lee: "That is not true"

Assemblyman Lee also questioned whether this personnel move was intended to disadvantage a specific individual.


He stated, "Appointing a bureau chief to head a department equivalent to Grade 5 can easily be interpreted as a significant disadvantage to that person's career. Isn't the intent to push them out of office?"


Governor Lee repeatedly stated, "There was no such intent," and said the appointment was made to properly handle matters related to the Geochang Incident.


◆ Appointing a Grade 5 official as acting bureau chief and issues with promotion-related training

The issue of appointing a Grade 5 official as acting chief of the Bureau of Safety and Construction, despite there being no vacancy caused by leave or business trip, was also brought into question.


Assemblyman Lee probed whether the appointment of a Grade 5 official as acting bureau chief in the absence of any vacancy was in accordance with the relevant regulations.


Governor Lee responded, "It was done to get the work done," but acknowledged that further verification was needed regarding possible violations of regulations.


Assemblyman Lee also presented evidence that certain newly promoted Grade 5 officials had completed approximately 19 hours and 15 minutes of cyber training in just one week, from June 3 to June 11, raising suspicions that they intensified their training in a short period to meet the necessary learning hours in anticipation of promotion.


Governor Lee denied the suspicions, stating, "There was no prior promise of promotion to any particular individual."


◆ Assemblyman Honghee Lee: "If the personnel measures are wrong, they must be corrected"

During the audit, Assemblyman Lee called the personnel department staff as witnesses to verify the process of drafting the initial personnel plan and whether preliminary reviews had taken place.


The personnel officer responded that the initial draft was prepared by the personnel department, and with regards to the assignment of the Grade 4 official as a department head, there were discussions concerning pending issues related to the Geochang Incident and the necessity for a suitable candidate.


Assemblyman Lee stressed, "There are legal limits to the discretion of the appointing authority," and urged, "If appointments violate laws or local regulations, they must be promptly corrected and measures developed to prevent recurrence."


Governor Lee responded, "Appointments must consider the organization as a whole and the performance of work," adding, "We will refer to the matters raised by the assembly today and do our utmost to abide by the relevant principles in the future."


The core issue raised in this audit was whether the discretion of the appointing authority had exceeded the legal and regulatory boundaries prescribed by laws and local ordinances.



If the review materials for the 88 exceptions to the transfer period, the legal basis for appointing the Grade 4 official to an equivalent Grade 5 post, the rationale for designating acting bureau chiefs, and documentation related to promotion reviews and mandatory training are released, the controversy over the appropriateness of these personnel actions is expected to become even more concrete.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing