[K-Women Talk] One Case, Three Women
On November 3, 1902, a murder took place in Sancheong. A woman named Kim Joi was found dead. Kim Joi had long suffered from domestic violence. Her husband, Kwon Wonjung, was a well-known figure from an influential Kwon family in the Sancheong area, but he squandered their fortune on gambling. Not stopping there, he also beat his wife and demanded money. Despite her dire circumstances, no one came to Kim Joi’s aid. She went back to her father’s house seeking help, but perhaps due to the era's fear of the stigma attached to divorced women rather than concerns about safety, her father, Kim Young-pal, sent her back to her husband’s home. He did pay off some of his son-in-law’s gambling debts, but her husband lost that money as well and resumed beating his wife.
Kim Joi died. Her father insisted it was murder. Her body was covered in dirt, and there were even footprints on her abdomen. However, her in-laws claimed Kim Joi hanged herself, and they hid Kwon Wonjung and coordinated their stories to obscure the truth. Then a decisive witness turned the situation around. Suwol, a slave from the Kwon household, specifically from Kim Joi’s home, came forward. Suwol testified that Kwon Wonjung beat Kim Joi to death, then staged a suicide with Kwon’s mother, Lee Joi, by hanging the body. In the third autopsy, signs of assault previously undiscovered were found all over Kim Joi’s body, and evidence emerged showing that she had been hanged after death to disguise the murder as a suicide.
Lee Joi was brought in as a person of interest and an accomplice. Lee Joi vehemently denied her son’s crime. Even during the cross-examination with Suwol, she merely expressed outrage, saying, "How could you do this?" At the very moment when the truth seemed about to be revealed, Lee Joi committed suicide in prison. Public opinion then shifted dramatically. With one woman dead and another having taken her own life, murmurs arose: “Did the interrogators go too far with their questioning?” The Kwon family amplified these sentiments, and the key witness, Suwol, recanted their testimony, claiming that they had lied under severe torture. As a result, suspicion turned to Kim Young-pal, Kim Joi’s father, with accusations that he blamed his daughter’s in-laws after sending her back to her death despite knowing of the domestic violence. After even a fifth autopsy, the case was ultimately closed as a suicide.
Strictly speaking, that’s almost what happened. Three years after the incident, in 1905, the court of Gyeongsang-do reopened the case, and Suwol testified again—this time again stating that Kwon Wonjung had beaten Kim Joi to death. Kwon Wonjung was finally found guilty of murdering his wife, and the true story of Kim Joi’s death came to light. Even though she died tragically—never having received good treatment from either her husband or her father—if her spirit remained, she surely would have found joy in the verdict delivered that day.
Why did Lee Joi take her son’s side? As his mother, she must have been well aware of his addiction to gambling and his domestic violence; perhaps she too was a victim of violence. Still, she chose to protect her son to the very end, even at the cost of her life. Just as Kim Joi had been abandoned by her own family, for Lee Joi, her world consisted of the Kwon household and her son, and she could not betray them. Lee Joi was a complex figure—an accomplice, a victim, and a perpetrator all at once.
The reason Suwol, the witness, recanted their statement is easy to understand. As a slave to the Kwon family, it would have been nearly impossible to go against their wishes and survive. Still, in the end, Suwol told the truth and revealed what really happened. Though the three women lived in the same place, their lives and deaths were entirely different.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Han Lee, historian
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.