As the ruling on the second investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) case filed by the Iranian Dayyani family against the Korean government is imminent, Yulchon LLC has been selected as the preferred negotiator to handle follow-up work. The first Dayyani ISDS was the first ISDS case that the Korean government lost.


The Ministry of Justice and other relevant government agencies opened bidding on August 25 to select a representative to handle the "post-arbitration award follow-up work for the second Dayyani ISDS" and designated Yulchon LLC as the preferred negotiator. This decision followed the notice of bidding on August 19. The main hearing for the second case concluded at the end of 2024, and the final decision is expected within this year.


Dayyani claimed that the Korean government violated the principles of fair and equitable treatment stipulated in the Korea–Iran Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT) when their company, Entekhab, attempted to acquire Daewoo Electronics in 2010–2011, and thus filed the first ISDS in 2015.


In 2018, the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) arbitral tribunal ordered the Korean government to pay approximately 73 billion won in compensation. In 2019, an annulment suit in a UK court was dismissed, confirming the Korean government's defeat. At that time, the domestic legal representative for the government was Yulchon LLC. Subsequently, in 2021, the Dayyani side filed a second ISDS, alleging that the government was passive in implementing the compensation payment procedure. From the second ISDS onwards, Peter & Kim took over as the domestic representative.


The Korean government, jointly with relevant ministries, obtained a special license from the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) of the U.S. Department of the Treasury in 2022 and proceeded to remit the compensation. However, the two parties continued to clash over part of the payment that could not be made due to domestic creditors' provisional seizures.


In legal circles, attention is being paid to the background of reinstating Yulchon LLC, which represented the government and lost in the first case, as the preferred negotiator for follow-up action, instead of Peter & Kim, which handled the main hearing of the second ISDS. Some analysts suggest that the goal is to respond swiftly to any potential annulment suit that the Dayyani side may file regarding the arbitration ruling, and to regroup before internal personnel changes at the Ministry of Justice following prosecution organization restructuring.



Jisoo Kim, Law Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing