"Negotiations Should Address Issues Like North Korea's Withdrawal from Ukraine After Implicitly Recognizing Its Nuclear Status"
Experts: "Official Recognition as a Nuclear State Is a Separate Matter"

There is a forecast from a former U.S. official that U.S. President Donald Trump could hold a summit meeting with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un first to resume dialogue, and then pursue additional talks after the upcoming midterm elections in November.


Anthony Ruggiero, a nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and former White House National Security Council (NSC) Director for North Korea during the first Trump administration, said in an interview released by PBS on the 28th (local time), "To make a prediction, I think President Trump will simply meet with Chairman Kim in some form to resume dialogue," in reference to the possibility of renewed North Korea-U.S. talks.


U.S. President Donald Trump posted a photo on his Truth Social on the 25th (local time) showing him together with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un at Panmunjom. Truth Social

U.S. President Donald Trump posted a photo on his Truth Social on the 25th (local time) showing him together with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un at Panmunjom. Truth Social

View original image

Former Director Ruggiero suggested that direct talks between President Trump and Chairman Kim could serve as a trigger to restart working-level negotiations, such as between ministers or deputy ministers.


He remarked, "A conversation between Chairman Kim and President Trump could prompt a resumption of such negotiations, and one can imagine a scenario in which a second summit takes place sometime after the midterm elections or next year.” In other words, President Trump could meet Kim Jong Un first to restart U.S.-North Korea dialogue, then pursue an additional summit meeting.


Ruggiero also argued that it is necessary to acknowledge the changed realities regarding the North Korean nuclear issue. He said that while he himself used to believe that denuclearization must be at the center of negotiations, his thinking has shifted recently.


Referring to the reality that North Korea has possessed nuclear weapons for a long time, he asserted that the United States could, at least implicitly, acknowledge this and shift the negotiation focus to more urgent issues. Specifically, he mentioned the withdrawal of North Korean forces from Ukraine and the suspension of military support to Russia.


However, he clarified that this does not mean formally recognizing North Korea as a nuclear-armed state. Ruggiero stated, "The question that the President and his advisers must consider is whether a meaningful agreement with North Korea can be reached, and whether the United States can manage other countries that might interpret this as a green light for their own nuclear armament."


He continued, evaluating that the United States still possesses sufficient incentives and deterrence measures to contain such risks. He did not specifically name countries that might consider pursuing their own nuclear armament.


Regarding the recent reduction of South Korea-U.S. joint military exercises, Ruggiero expressed that he was not surprised. He commented, "The only thing that surprised me was that President Trump did not do this last year," explaining that President Trump has strong views on the joint exercises.


Rachel Minyoung Lee, a senior fellow at the U.S. think tank Stimson Center, who also appeared in the interview, assessed that it is realistically difficult to set denuclearization as the starting point of negotiations.


Senior Fellow Lee stated, "Given the current reality, it is virtually impossible to start or even include the word 'denuclearization' in any agenda with North Korea," but emphasized that this does not mean politically recognizing North Korea as a nuclear weapon state.


She noted that accepting the reality that North Korea possesses nuclear weapons and politically recognizing its nuclear-armed status as North Korea demands are two separate matters. She evaluated that, under current circumstances, even simply reopening the ‘New York channel’, the working-level communication link between North Korea and the U.S., would be significant progress.


Senior Fellow Lee also analyzed that North Korea now holds a much stronger negotiating position than it did during the last North Korea-U.S. summit in 2019. Not only has it survived years of international sanctions and COVID-19 lockdowns, but its ties with Russia have recently strengthened, and China has also expanded high-level exchanges with North Korea, thereby increasing Pyongyang’s leverage in negotiations.


In contrast, Bruce Klingner, senior fellow at the Mansfield Foundation, cautioned that opening a summit first requires careful consideration. He noted that while President Trump prefers major agreements that he can claim as his achievements, North Korea is likely to employ so-called ‘salami tactics’—gaining concessions and rewards in stages.



Klingner argued that North Korea could demand compensation simply for attending talks and then continue demanding further concessions. He stated that a ‘bottom-up’ approach—with sufficient working-level negotiations prior to any summit—is the preferable path.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing